upvote
Not only bartering has never been the default mean of exchange, but also the idea that money were created to optimize the trading process is also wrong.

For an item to become currency in a society, it must already be something people value independently of its use as money, and people must expect others to accept it as well. Say the villagers live near the sea and find some beautiful shiny stones that everyone wants. Those stones can then become currency.

A good example of this is tobacco in colonial America. It came to be used as currency because it was already widely traded and valued.

reply
This is obviously not an attempt at anything remotely resembling documentary history. It’s more of a just so story explaining what problem each step solved.

Unless of course one thinks that smooth gray stones from a riverbed two miles away reflects some historically significant point in money’s evolution.

reply
I'm not going to explain David Graeber's Debt to you, but yes, this exact 18th century fantasy of the emergence of money in caveman times contains the same kind of misunderstandings that also leads to most people having an incredibly misguided view of how the contemporary global financial system operates.
reply