upvote
AI improves a student's ability to learn. It does nothing to improve a student's motivation to learn.

Motivating students to learn is not at all a solved task. And arguably a harder one too. Even the ~2010 "Google and grit" self-teaching is enough to outperform public education - but most students don't have the motivation to pull that off in practice. They have the opportunity, but that matters little if they don't use it.

reply
No, they think they learn, then when they need to use that knowledge it turns out they learned nothing.
reply
Exactly. Calculators didn't make the typical person great at math. They obviated mastery of math.
reply
Math or arithmetic ? Math isn’t arithmetic any more than juggling is theoretical physics.

Mastery of arithmetic involves memorizing lots of heuristic rules that aren’t particularly insightful about, or are outright conflicting with, the structure of math, and learning the structure of math first slows your ability to do arithmetic.

I don’t think any school hands first graders calculators and asks them to never learn arithmetic. But I see no need once you’re doing algebra to be focusing your time on long division or multiplication. These are irrelevant distractions from algebra, time spent and points lost on arithmetic details is a waste of cognition and doesn’t help. This becomes increasingly true through calculus, linear algebra, until you get to real math courses where a calculator is pointless because arithmetic doesn’t even show up.

reply
Multiplication needs to be automatic for doing algebra: FOIL and factoring polynomials immediately come to mind.

Long division, at least conceptually, is also present in algebra and partial fractions.

reply
Similarly, algebra needs to be automatic to do calculus.

Everything builds on everything else.

reply
That's a very attractive idea. KhanMigo was supposed to embody that potential. Seems like it hasn't.

Some kids really enjoy learning. Never mind merely solving an educational assessments problem, personalized learning seems like it has the potential to unlock a lot of intellect across the population. And yet.

reply
There is a 99% probability this will not happen in your lifetime. Half the point of school is so someone has supervision over children for 6 hours and to be part of a small community.

If anything, if someone is looking for an AI proof job while not wanting to do something braindead, teaching might be one of the good jobs that may get more competitive.

reply
Modern public education is just state subsidized daycare to keep the population at their 9-5.
reply