upvote
The issue with libraries which offer you portable simd is that the auto vectorizer of the compiler will likely generate faster code.
reply
The autovectorizer afaik rarely emits optimizations for the different vector units to support + efficiently caches the CPUid check to happen once on program start. It’s a good baseline but the continuum (today) is scalar -> auto vectorized -> portable SIMD -> hand rolled explicit. That portable SIMD lets you bridge into hand rolled explicit ergonomically is a power auto-vectorization doesn’t have. Either the compiler does it or doesn’t but you have no way to even have a check that says “fail to build the program if this function isn’t vectorized”. This is important if you’re relying on that property and someone accidentally adds a data dependency and breaks the optimization without you realizing. Portable and explicit SIMD don’t have this problem by definition.
reply