upvote
If you are building for yourself instead of buying from someone else, you haven’t unlocked any value in the economic sense. Perhaps by making NVIDIA richer, but who knows how much they have indirectly spent through AI companies these years to get your couple dollars a month back to Jensen’s pocket.
reply
deleted
reply
A company/person that writes its/their own application that shaves 1% off capex or opex will absolutely unlock value in the economic sense.
reply
> If you are building for yourself instead of buying from someone else, you haven’t unlocked any value in the economic sense.

The articles says "AI needs $6T in annual revenue."

That is definitely adding to the annual revenue figure.

reply
It appears that out of a desperate urge to show your "Well Actually" Club Card that you've proved their entire point.
reply
GDP is known to have shortcomings. The example from HN a bit ago is mowing the lawn. If I mow my own lawn and my neighbor mows there, the GDP doesn't move. If I mow my neighbors for $200 and they mow mine for $200, $400 gets added to the GDP. So the software I wrote for myself won't show up in any GDP calculation. How happy (or not) I am over that software doesn't show up in the GDP. My subscription to the AI provider is the only thing that will. Now, will that, multiplied over millions of users reach $6T? I have no idea. GDP is a metric like any other and is just as subject to Goodhart's law.
reply
You explained the problem brilliantly. Frontier models are great at making you tinker and come up with shit you wouldn’t have done because there is zero value in it and you would have had to bet a value N (time, money) to obtain before this investors-subsidized almost-free software existed. This is deluding individuals and CEOs and everyone who seems incapable to abstract from the sycophantic personal experience into systemic thinking. To be fair, LLMs have been engineered to give this illusion, so the fault lies with the grifters controlling them.

Now are there useful applications of these tools (not gods) that might justify a sizeable new tech market? Absolutely yes! Is that market ever be going to be worth trillions a year? LOL hell no.

reply
So you've unlocked tremendous value, but you're not earning any money?

So where is the value? Have you built that one application you always wished existed but it wasn't available?

reply
> Have you built that one application you always wished existed but it wasn't available?

Yes, more than one and I use them a lot. Not being good at design and not liking front-end, among a few other things, work always stopped from from building them before,

> So you've unlocked tremendous value, but you're not earning any money?

No, I also don't make money from my coffee machine, but it provides value.

reply
The idea would be its deflationary I guess. Your dollar goes further with these tools.
reply