upvote
His presentation style may be no-nonsense, but the content is brimming with nonsense. I would like to hear Greg Kroah-Hartman explain how the Mythos output was 'only 10 real bugs' but there were simultaneously over 1300 CVEs issued last month. It seems not much counts as a 'real bug' when an LLM comes up with it, but when it's time to bully distros into shipping an LTS release, anything goes?
reply
What he means is that the headline-grabbing mythos output amounted to 10 actual bugs out of 79^H6 (and all of those got CVEs because that's how linux does it). The other 1300 CVEs came from other sources (the big increase likely being everyone else running LLMs through the codebase and filtering through the false positives). The Mythos output is mainly meant as an example of how even the top-tier models still have a high false-positive rate and that can be pretty tiring to deal with.

I do think he repeats some myths in the video, or at least confidently states some things that are not demonstrated to be true, but his core point of 'you still gotta check these things' seems pretty solid.

reply
> he repeats some myths in the video, or at least confidently states some things that are not demonstrated to be true

I am genuinely curious what the myths/unproven things he states - I watched the video and it's repetitive sure but not much felt controversial to me.

reply
Every bugfix is assigned a CVE.

"the CVE assignment team is overly cautious and assign CVE numbers to any bugfix that they identify. This explains the seemingly large number of CVEs that are issued by the Linux kernel team."

https://docs.kernel.org/process/cve.html

reply
Fair point, but he was talking about Mythos in particular and the point wasn't so much that LLMs will always have false positives rather he was saying they are causing a lot of them right now and how to deal with it.

Also as other replies said Linux kernel process is to assign CVE to everything - some of them may be just DDOSes, very hard to exploit and everything in between. All of them are bugs so they all get fixed and it's not a bad thing if distros ship those fixes and people update their kernel.

reply