upvote
Well that would depend on your interest rate, presumably. Especially since interest is tax deductible in some places.

If you _do_ break up, this also makes it harder for one person to keep the house, which might be bad if there's kids in a local school, etc. If you have 100k in equity it's easier to buy out your ex than if you have 1 million in equity.

reply
Mathematically, yes, it depends on the interest rate. Over the reality of how humans work is people who pay their house off early are the type of people who tend to make other good financial decisions. And so paying off your house early is good advice even though it seems like it shouldn't be by any mathematical means. If you are the exception that actually has the discipline to invest in things that are better than a house Again, assuming common interest rates and other investments available - you are better off, but the reality is that type of person doesn't exist.
reply
What if you have a mortgage with 2.5% interest? Even if I had enough liquid assets to pay it off, I wouldn’t with the current market.
reply
It's about individual tolerance for risk and ability to sleep at night knowing that the bank still holds the title to your house.
reply
> knowing that the bank still holds the title to your house.

While the bank holds the title on a financed car, they don't actually hold title on your house. They will have a recorded lien, of course. But you hold the title, which should help you sleep ;p.

That's why a house is foreclosed, and a car is repossessed. Repo is lender calls the tow peeps and they pick up your car; foreclosure requires notice and often court and plenty of bureaucracy.

Neither option is fun, of course.

On topic, I was paying a little extra on my mortgage (mostly as I rate adjusted down, I would tend to keep paying the old payment), but when savings interest is more than mortgage interest, it was just as easy to sleep with a savings balance equal to the mortgage balacne as with no mortgage.

reply
What is the issue with the bank holding the title? Sure, you lose the house if you can't make the payments to the bank, but you also lose the house if you can't make the tax payments to the government. In both situations (with or without a mortgage), you never truly own it.
reply
In general your tax payment is much lower than your house payment, and so if you can pay the house off, you will have or should have no problem paying the taxes. Watch the local politics because everyone saw this does fail but it is pretty rare overall. Meanwhile people do lose their job and the payment portion of the house is a lot of money and so you can lose your job just because bad luck and in turn you lost your house.

Or to put it a different way, if my house was paid for, it would hurt, but I could make all ends meet just working fast food jobs. It wouldn't be an easy life, I'd end up walking a few miles to the nearest fast food place because I couldn't afford a car, but I could at least keep my house.

reply
The math may not be optimal but your sleep will be.
reply