upvote
> Ultimately people want to learn about new products and services and new companies that couldn't ever advertise anywhere would die off.

I want to learn about products that are useful to me, but not through ads. As it turns out, it is incredibly difficult to learn about new products that are useful, as those do not tend to show up in ads at all and even seeking them out is very difficult.

It's weird how no one has come together to make a website specifically designed around users finding product categories that will make their life better. For example, I didn't learn about height adjustable desks from an ad. Nor did I learn about balance boards from an ad. Or trackballs. Or essentially every other product that made my life better once I realized that product category exists.

reply
> Ultimately people want to learn about new products and services

Yes, and those people are free to visit equivalent of mail order catalog or go to the store or subscribe to consumer goods quality testing journal or to any of the enthusiast magazines about electronics or gardening or whatever where they perform independent testing and benchmarking or look up a video comparing ceiling fans across a century when they feel hot in the summer.

So yes, we should absolutely ban third party advertisements. People will still be able to discover good products.

reply
> You can never get rid of advertising entirely.

What a myopic view. Also, the world is very much filled with shades of gray. I’m certain this dichotomy is indeed a false one.

reply
> Ultimately people want to learn about new products and services

Maybe I'm just not a typical person, but I have never woken up in the morning and said to myself, "You know, I would just love for a corporation to help me learn about their new products and services today." Never. Not even once. When I want to learn about something, I will actively seek information out about it, and I'm not going to look to advertisements for impartial information. The purpose of advertising is never to inform. It's to bombard and saturate.

reply
You are 100% typical in this. Advertising is the opposite of informing.
reply
Nobody claims one can get rid of it entirely. Nothing in this world is black and white, there are always shades of gray.

We also cant get rid of cancer, it doesnt mean we shoudl close down all hospitals.

reply