upvote
people are very good at seeing their pets conforming to their expectations, whether that is scientifically true or not :)

https://www.sciencenews.org/article/dog-breed-individual-beh...

> Breed offers little predictive value for individuals, explaining just 9% of variation in behavior.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abk0639

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/which-dog-breed-s... (here note how big the overlap is between breeds for most traits, and clumpiness is rare, but present)

reply
Only an anecdote, but our orange cat doesn't really conform to any of the stereotypes. He so smart he taught himself how to open doors.
reply
Another anecdata - my cat growing up was orange, and he was plenty smart. He was very relaxed/chill but would come when called and was an excellent hunter of the house mice.

His mom was a very intelligent calico (she communicated with people impressively well), and his dad was an unknown feral cat, so I think his smart-cat genes were more noticeable than whatever correlates with orange.

reply
So did my orange. He learned to open doors so he can maybe get some food.

He doesn't play with any of the cat toys (our other cat loves those and begs to play), is barely active and only runs (his whole belly jiggles side-to-side when he's running) after his dental treats which we throw so he can get some exercise.

He's an odd ball for sure. Goofy, loving. A little chubby, but the vet says it is probably fine considering his laziness and he is healthy otherwise (knock-wood).

I LOVE MY ORANGE CAT LOL

reply
There's the "my anecdote trumps those scientists facts" guy. Never fails.
reply
Humans carry this GTPase as well. GTP is energy source of receptors called G protein coupled receptors. They are about 750 these and many of them are catecholamine receptors, like the serotonin and dopamine receptors.

Humans also carry this gene. https://www.uniprot.org/uniprotkb/Q6ZRI8/entry

In humans, both DNA and RNA are mostly expressed in the brain and in the endocrine system.

https://www.proteinatlas.org/ENSG00000147256-ARHGAP36/tissue

For cats it very well may be different. Genes do not express activity the same indifferent species and they’re definitely not the same in different parts of the body. Genes can express RNA in one part of the body and more DNA and another part.

But I think this deletion is really about how it affects the methylation the gene.

reply
Wait until you find out about the thousands of anecdotal reports from parents about “sugar rush” in their kids- also without foundation
reply