upvote
> And they won't release the code.

This is the weirdest part, because you know, coding is solved, so anyone could create their own one, so why not publish it?

reply
They want you to vibecode this using Claude.
reply
Because then everyone would be able to see what a total piece of trash it is

And by the way things are done at this company, it's almost a given their whole codebase are litter'd with embarassing shit like hardcoded paths, server secrets, weirdo comments picked up from some random chat context and immortalized through Claude speak, etc. There's no way they'd be able to open source anything.

But all of this is besides the point -- the product was never a source control system (who cares about that anymore?), the product is _the narrative_. It does not matter if everything withers and dies as long as the narrative survives, and by that measure I'd say the goal has been achieved.

reply
That my thought when I saw online only, we're back to Subversion.

You think you have it bad now when GitHub goes down, wait until you're stuck with an online only client.

reply
I think offline work is increasingly impossible these days, or at least so hindered that there's no reason to optimize for it (especially with how reliable internet access is). Imagine working at Anthropic and not having access to Claude. Google has been online-only for a long time now.
reply
Hard disagree, for the vast majority of Dev work this is not the case.
reply
You don't use cloud AI for the vast majority of dev work?
reply
claude is also online-only so i doubt they mind
reply
Perforce was fine. It just had a terrible ui and didn’t allow me to code on the beach.

If I were still manually merging conflicts the p4merge tool was GOAT

I used it in git

reply
Yeah pretty much Perforce.
reply
Oh the SVN days, brought back memories
reply