upvote
It's like during the covid era where CDC and WHO recommended against wearing masks. Anyone dared questioning it was branded anti-sciene.
reply
Right. I think there are two cases here:

Legitimate idiots who somehow acquire professional titles/positions. Things like "Florida surgeon removes wrong organ."

Then you can have honest mistakes by otherwise good practitioners.

What I want from my doctors and dentists is a sort of consultative collaboration, but the systems (in the US) are optimizing for transactions.

reply
What is authority when it is not unquestioned?
reply
>and almost certainly more than you will ever know

That's something you should question. While Doctors know more than you about medicine in general, one usually does not have to do a lot of research to know more about their specific ailment than the family doctor does.

reply
I'll give a specific example. It's 2016. I've just eaten out at a restaurant near the ocean. Within an hour or two, most of my body has turned bright pink, like sunburn, and I soon develop terrible diarrhea to go with it, along with intense digestive system pain. Come morning, all symptoms have vanished and I feel fine.

It wasn't that hard to find out what caused this.

But about a year later, we had a couple of med students staying with us, and before I even got to the end of the symptoms, they asked me specifically if I had eaten one very particular kind of fish (which is actually illegal in many nations and even some US states). They didn't even bat an eyelid, and they were of course 100% correct.

Yes, I can "do my own research", but fitting that into an overall view of drug and physiology interactions is something quite different, as is simply knowing stuff that for other people is complete arcane knowledge.

reply
According to Gemini, those symptoms indicate Scombroid Fish Poisoning (also known as Histamine Fish Poisoning), which can occur with a variety of improperly refrigerated fish, including things like Tuna, Mahi Mahi, etc - none of which are banned.

Wat was the correct answer that your med students guessed?

reply