upvote
I would like to give a real world example of this too.

If you want to do something artistic or start a business based around Art, Montreal is perfect for it, for the very same reason above.

Initially the govt invested in the arts to preserve French culture, which resulted in a lot of art infrastructure being made, cheap ateliers, fabric suppliers, paint suppliers, &c. Which attracted a lot of artists, which then increases the demand for the art infrastructure, which makes the city easy to make art in.

It makes it stupid easy to make stuff and find the skilled artisans you need to make it. Much easier than any other Canadian city I've lived in.

reply
Just curious which city is the best city for computer system programming?
reply
Santa Clara, CA. Lots of computer systems around.
reply
Depends what "best" means. Best city for cheapest workers in that area? Best city for highest paying employers in that area? Just these two would yield different cities.
reply
Galesburg Illinois
reply
The Hollywood case has a quirk that is relevent to the extensional content of HN:

West coast filmmakng started in the Bay Area (at the time the largest conurbation in the west) but moved south because of the year 'round weather.

But why the west? Because Edison controlled the filmmaking patents and demanded not just royalties but script oversight as well. By moving west, they could ignore the patents because they were simply too hard to enforce from such a long distance.

So ironically, given how things worked out, IP piracy is at the root of Hollywood.

reply
Yep, but Edison is long gone, while Hollywood kept compounding over time. There's zero other reasons Hollywood is _currently_ better than any other place for filmmaking.
reply
The term you’re looking for is “path dependence” and I was agreeing with you.

The only reason I even commented was because IP issues are popular and relevant on HN

reply
Also, how it stops to be. Specializations like that get disrupted if there's an easier way to make money (aka Resource curse, aka Dutch Disease [1]).

Same thing with Israel -- if they had some easier way to make moneys they would go for it. But constant demand from their defense kept if afloat.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse

reply
Regarding the Netherlands, it doesn't hurt that TSMC happened to be cofounded by the same Dutch company that spun out ASML
reply
Yep, exactly my point "small change in initial parameters".
reply