To be fair, ME3's ending was doomed before that game started.
replyI'd place it around the start of ME2.
ME2's ending was just terrible. The boss fight was ridiculously cheesy.
replyIn contrast, ME1's ending may have well been a master class in game cinematography and writing.
The entirety of Mass Effect 1 was a master class in writing, from the opening cinematic to the ending credits, that more than made up for somewhat janky (though nevertheless entertaining) gameplay.
replyI think the Mass Effect games were very flashy but the gameplay elements were pretty shallow. It felt like all the dialog led to the same outcomes, you could be a paragon and give all the "good" replies to conversation or give all the edgy renegade replies and the story would proceed the same way. It kind of felt like it gave you the illusion of choice without actually giving you any real choice. I think it was endemic to the 2000's era RPG's Fallout 4 had exactly the same problem.
replyThe combat wasn't very engaging either it was a boring feeling cover shooter. None of your character abilities or gear or anything seemed to have much of an effect.
Are there any games you like that you felt did give you a real significant choice in how the story played out?
replyGoing back to the 90's the Original Fallout games (the Turn based ones) would give you different endings depending on the choices you made through out the game. Most recently Baldur's Gate 3.
replyEdit: Deus Ex series too
Much of ME2's story is terrible (some of the side character stuff is delightful, but the 'main quest' is a train wreck).
replyMy point was that ME3 was doomed because ME2 utterly failed at bridging the gap between the strong start of an epic that was ME1 and what should have been the conclusion in ME3.
In fact 'fail' may be generous. I don't think it even 'tried'.
"probing uranus" was so worth it tho
replyI always thought this was a hot take but I agree!
replyTrue.. it is genuinely hard to deliver on that kind of a build up.
replyAt least you can pick the color filter to apply to the ending.
replyThe studio's biggest sin came before that when they used DLC to paywall off major parts of the story in ME2. Anyone who didn't fork over even more of their cash got an incomplete game and a plot that made no sense.
replyThe only major part of story of ME2 that got paywalled is the Lair of the Shadow Broker and I don't feel like I missed much by not playing it (at least on my first playthrough, second I had the DLC). And even if you take a ME2 save with that DLC to ME3, I felt like ME3 does a decent job of explaining what had happened.
replythey could go from infamously bad ending to one of most creative endings ever by just saying indoctrination theory is correct
reply“It was all a dream” nonsense IMO. It’s fun to play with that idea, but I’d find that a lame cop out ultimately.
replyMeh I liked it. In fact they shouldn’t have caved and added to it IMO.
reply