upvote

    > 1. there are 57,000 unoccupied apartments in NYC because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out.
The correct quote should be:

    > According to state data, approximately 57,421 rent-stabilized apartments were vacant across New York City
The key term here is "rent-stabilized". And the reasons why they are vacant is much more complex "because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out". That is simply one category of rent-stabilized apartments that are vacant.
reply
I don't think it's much more complicated than that. If you own a "rent-stabilized" apartment there's going to be a very low limit to the amount of money you're willing to spend to keep it habitable. If it needs a lot of money to make it legal to rent out, you're just going to leave it vacant. You don't really have a choice.
reply
> And the reasons why they are vacant is much more complex "because city regulations on rents make them unprofitable to rent out".

Is it actually more complex than that? If the regulation that makes it unprofitable to rent them out is rent control, that's still an accurate statement of why they're not being rented out.

reply
> there are 57,000 unoccupied apartments in NYC

That's about 2.4% of the total number of rented apartments, and about 1.5% of the total housing stock.

How long do you think those apartments are unoccupied, on average?

What portion of the stock do you think would normally be healthy to have on the market?

reply
google prompt: "how many unoccupied apartments in nyc"

Scroll down a bit and read the section: "Key Causes of Vacancies"

reply
[flagged]
reply
I genuinely can not understand how anyone with basic knowledge of economics could believe that government intervention is not responsible for the majority of rent price increases

The market, left to its own, will keep building because someone will see the prices people are willing to pay and think “I want in on that” but then the government comes in and blocks them from building. No building = supply lower than demand which always equals higher costs

Further, It would only have taken you one 5 second search to see the ways government regulations can cause unoccupied apartments

https://www.google.com/search?q=in+what+ways+can+government+...

reply
That's because you inserted the word "all" which was quite absent from what I wrote.

Please try again.

P.S. google "how many unoccupied apartments in nyc"

reply
> all unoccupied apartments in a market

Which market are you thinking of?

reply
Let's assume I'm talking about the same market as the person I responded to.
reply
> the same market as the person I responded to

Los Angeles? Where the homeowner vacancy rate is 0.7% and rental vacancy 4%?

If you literally weren't thinking of anywhere when your responded, where did you get the notion from?

[1] https://api.census.gov/data/missing_key.html +/- one percent

reply