undefined

points

[-]

IIUC, your point is that changing IDE settings will affect other developers. But can't you enable an inspection locally, apply all or some of the quickfixes and revert the setting before committing? In the longterm, you want to enable the inspection anyway because the point is to prevent developers or agents from comitting new code that violates it (agents can access JetBrains IDEs' MCP Server to get inspection results).

Of course, crashes and bugs can happen when applying quickfixes, which isn't nice. Ideally, they should be reported and fixed. You can also ask an agent to fix the occurences instead of using the IDE quickfixes if that's blocking you.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that IDEs shouldn't make that process harder, they can actually improve agents' results. For example, you don't need to write custom skills to prevent agents from writing some class of bugs if the IDE can detect it and agents have access to the results.

> Changing 200K+ lines of code yourself is a nightmare (and to prove it still does the same thing afterwards).

If an agent does it, you still have no proof, but okay.

Full disclosure, I work at JetBrains, but not in the IDE department.

by BatteryMountain53 minutes ago|

parent|

[-]

The problem is, even if I only enforce some rules locally, another developer has a different set of rules. So when we git commit, we ping-pong changes and fix each others stuff over and over again, bloating commits. We used editor config files + analyzer configs in the past (that gets checked into version control too), but there were still too much friction.

Where now, the compiler flags & strict analyzer settings forces claude to do the right things (we explicitly tell claude not try and bypass or lower the barrier). I think it only works because we don't spend 95% of our time in the IDE anymore like a couple of years back, so we as developers no longer feel that friction, as claude tries to satisfy the compiler instead. Its a massive mental load that is just gone, we haven't had any conversations in meeting about this kinda stuff anymore (remember in the past we would have flameouts in meetings or code reviews about linter settings...).