upvote
The lack of immigration problems is one reason why the talent is less expensive. The other reason is probably because people in Canada get compensated in other ways. Many of my American friends who left Canada for employment eventually return when their kids reach school age because they can't stomach the harsh reality of the US education system. Or something happens to their health.

It's easy to knock Canada for its personal income tax rate, but compared to European alternatives, it's still quite low, despite offering a whole lot of baseline public goods.

reply
The deal used to be that it cost less to live here, so the lower pay was mostly made up for. Now it doesn't because housing costs hyper-inflated under low interest rates, lax regulation, and high immigration.

That said, while senior SWE salaries here absolutely not even close to competitive with the Bay Area or NYC they are not that far off from other places in the US (like smaller midwest cities etc). While Canadian salary packages are depressed, it's also partially a result of: they're not inflated.

The bigger concern is more the lack of interesting work.

reply
And a lot don’t leave if their spouse can’t work in the US (or has no interest in being sah). I know lots with partners who would never give up their Canadian gov pension track. That and other family obligations make it harder to move.
reply
Yep. In the mid-2000s when we first got married and had young kids my wife worked for Apple Canada, and I worked for a company that was just getting acquired by Google. We could easily have just both company-transferred to the Bay Area and made 3x the money and had much nicer weather. My mother-in-law had just passed away (fuck Cancer, etc) and there was little tying us here family wise. But choices were made: Canadian public school system vs US, being a citizen and secure in that here (vs insecure visa status), I wanted a rural property and to live rural (which would not have been a viable option there), etc. etc. For better or for worse we stayed here.

Many do similar calculations. Home is home. It's profoundly arrogant (and very American) to assume that the "best talent" moves for money and opportunity.

Americans have very high labour mobility rates, and often assume that's how the whole world works. But in most places in the world the idea of uprooting your whole life for a job is seen as odd.

reply