upvote
Ok, sure, then let’s just remove all options except adaptive thinking at default reasoning level and see how that goes with Claude users. I’m sure they’ll appreciate the reduced friction.

Just because it would be nice to have that, doesn’t mean that it’s a good idea in practice, or that there currently exists a viable way to implement it.

> At any price point, there exists the best model/effort combination.

People are already offended by any barely perceptible tweaks to models; can’t wait to hear what they think about having their options reduced to whatever Anthropic decides is the pareto-optimal “do the thinky thing” setting this week.

reply
You said it yourself, removing the option won't go well with basically any user today, and classifiers will remain fallible forever, so it won't be.

Yet, current non-users simply don't care about reading 4 system cards during roll-in and then keeping up with new ones every few weeks.

And, a solid adaptive thinking classifier is trivial compared to Anthropic's remaining tech stack. Task complexity estimation and model/effort selection are simple predictions with clear proxies in current data and millions of training samples generated daily by current users.

reply