upvote
Generators go on the 17th floor so they can vent out exhaust and heat. Pumps need to go in the basement because you can only suck a liquid up by one atmosphere, which is something like 30' for diesel, but you can push a liquid up basically as high as you want. (Also, stating the obvious, the diesel tanker trucks are gonna be street-level, so you'd need pumps there anyway if you put the actual tanks higher.) This does, are you're pointing out, kinda stink if the pump itself is flooded, but the design's common and does make sense
reply
In firefighting it is quite common to take in surface water using a submersible pump which is hydraulically driven by an engine on land - like the fire truck or a dedicated diesel. See for example [0][1]. Doing it this way means you aren't limited by elevation and don't need to carry special suction hoses for water intake.

It makes me wonder if anyone is paranoid enough to do the same for highrise fuel pumps: sure, the basement may flood, but when the pump in there is designed to flood it's a lot less of a problem! Place the actual power source several floors up, where flooding is impossible outside a The Day After Tomorrow-esque civilization-ending catastrophe and you should be fine.

[0]: https://hytrans.com/product/hydrosub-150/

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pLJT4On5naA

reply
I see. I thought it was an emergency power generator they brought in for this incident. When you see that sort of thing for buildings, usually it's just a big trailer on the sidewalk hooked up to the building mains.
reply
Probably on the 17th floor to put the generators closer to the loads and reduce transmission losses. Also reduces street level air and noise emissions (and avoids street level air intake)

With fuel storage on the same floor for a reasonable runtime, larger fuel storage in the basement and a pump (or two) to move fuel, you're well prepared for lots of things. As long as the fuel throughput on the stairs is better than the fuel use rate, then you're ok for as long as you've got people to move it. Which is ok for exceptional incidents.

reply
More than likely that's where the available space was. Data centers many large generators and there may not always be space in the lower levels to fit them, especially if the data center was not one of the original tenants.
reply
Ground floor risks flood damage presumably? But this doesn’t explain why the 17th was chosen.
reply
You put them up there so you get a voltage boost from the gravity pushing the electricity down. Put the generators on the ground floor, and by the time the electricity reached the top, there would be a voltage drop.
reply
Factoring in gravity isn't good physics or engineering. Gravity's effect is negligible in a generator placement in a skyscraper
reply
I think it was a joke?
reply
Something something sarcasm can neither be created nor destroyed
reply
No joke - have you ever tried to siphon electricity? Can't do it more than 35 feet or so. You'll be boiling off your electrons into a plasma by the time you get to that height.
reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
Carrying the diesel fuel up 18 flights of stairs also enhances its potential energy. About 47 Joules per foot.

You get out of it what you put into it. ;)

reply