upvote
It's something to reference. My view is that it's better than "doesn't load for me".
reply
How is it garbage? It's crowdsourced monitoring so sure, there will be false positives (especially when aws/cloudflare/azure/bgp services have a bad day), but it's one of the best indicators to quickly know if _something_ is going on.
reply
Yeah, but the methodology means that normies are going to inaccurately blame AWS and Google (both are down right now according to downdetector)
reply
At least it reports the numbers they are getting, you can see that outlook has 130k reports while AWS only has 1.3k.
reply
What's your preferred alternative?
reply
Ping?
reply
Apparently Outlook, Gmail, etc are all working on the server at 192.168.1.1 then - ping says it's responding just fine
reply
Full Disclosure, this is a Cisco product and I work there.

ThousandEyes Internet Insights offers a public outage map at https://www.thousandeyes.com/outages/ that is MASSIVELY more accurate (and faster to detect) than Down Detector because its based on actual telemetry and not on crowdsourcing.

reply
Thank you for the recommendation!

They indicate sharepoint is getting blown out... again.

reply
still down :)
reply
Honestly I trust downdetector more than that. Crowdsourcing always wins.
reply
Downdetector said basically everything was down today (including Google, AWS, etc.) but they aren't affected. This makes me NOT trust downdetector.
reply
It is ironic that this outage map _also_ is not loading for me right now
reply
Yes, just to confirm, it seems that our platform is getting hammered at the moment and it's causing the page to take a long time to load or intermittently load. We are looking into it.
reply
It is back up now.

There will be a more detailed message when we finish the SII on our status page at the link I previously provided, but the short version is we took way more traffic than normal to our platform and the related workers were running out of memory.

reply
[dead]
reply
it seems to be down... lol
reply
LOL. Share defaults to X.com
reply
seems smart to link to the most popular platform by default. there's other share links at the bottom for the less popular ones
reply
The public outage map is primarily a marketing page, because customers receive deeper insights in-product. Given that most people discuss outages live/up-to-the-minute on Twitter, that is why its where we default to sharing.
reply
The snarky but honest response is HackerNews/Reddit. But if you're trying for something that actually checks the sites you point it at instead of relying on users reporting "issues", a buddy of mine runs https://onlineornot.com/ and it seems generally more reliable.
reply
Back in the golden days you could just go to search.twitter.com, search "AWS", and sort by recent.
reply
Still can. AWS Status pages are still terrible. See HN for the outage a year ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45640838
reply
> Still can.

No. It requires an account now, and they did away with the recent posts firehose.

reply
"Start Free Trial" -- uh, no thanks. You seem skeptical of crowd sourcing. Enjoy your Encyclopedia Brittanica.
reply
My extensive DDoS bot network... er I mean my distributed website validation platform!
reply
deleted
reply
It seems like one of the best methodologies there is? Real people reporting real outages of a service they use?

I often know about outages dozens of minutes in advance of it being posted on official channels (or in the case of AWS, three days later...).

So what if the resolution is low because people can't log in to Fortnite and an Azure outage gets shown as an Epic Games outage. Doesn't matter. The live feed is incredibly reassuring from a "down for anyone else this instant, before official status page has a chance to see it?" Saves me so much time knowing whether it's a me-or-them issue.

reply
At the other extreme is Microsoft's own dashboard (https://azure.status.microsoft/en-us/status) whose methodology is so "rigorous" that it probably won't show anything about today's outage until next week, if at all!
reply
Since this isn’t an Azure outage why would that page show anything ever?
reply
Still more reliable than most of the status pages that even lie after the outages
reply
As someone who ends up being unofficial downdetector-primary at a company, dealing with this shit and the fact that people cannot comprehend its mis-attribtion wastes so much of my time.
reply
not really, soon as i had a problem with outlook i went there and already saw user reports and a massive spike confirming it wasn't anything on my end.
reply