upvote
I am not a cynic, but a realist. It is easy to do things when you put a ton of money towards the effort so I find this nothing special. Maybe when I was a child these things would fascinate me, but they are just engineering.

So, what would amaze me? Ending homelessness in the United States. Because that takes more than money. I would like to swap the "passion" or engineering for the "compassion" of ending suffering. Very easy to shape and change material things, very hard to change the heart.

The people you want to share your excitement might be suffering under the same separation of wealth that made this landing possible. (Yet there is little talk that they failed to catch the booster and it exploded).

reply
Me and four other engineering graduates just sat and watched this around a big TV in my mates apartment in Sydney, and what we saw was an amazing team, delivering amazing engineering results. Just take a win for humanity for once.
reply
Homelessness is largely driven by personal choice and by our desire to not compel the "unhoused" into mental institutions where they'd probably be better served.

There are ample government and private support mechanisms, including housing and food, but most choose not to take advantage.

reply
> Ending homelessness in the United States

You don't need private people/companies or more taxes for that. US has enough resources to do it already. Maybe you should go ask your politicians, better yet, ask your friends/neighbors/yourself if you are ready to take the drastic steps necessary to solve that.

reply
Well to start off, I am homeless, so I can’t really ask myself for help with that.

But imagine engineering hearts so that we did not have to ask?

reply
Of course, you should not need to ask, in a better world.

If govt really cared about it, more than that, if (most) PEOPLE really cared about it, it should be top 3 priority of any govt in any country.

- Govt should build massive cheap hotel-type housing spaces (full free) equipped with bare minimum necessities like roof, heating, food, basic healthcare (not million $ free cancer treatment).

- Mandatory drug rehabilitation (if applicable)

- Mandatory job search/placement/training

- Jail with forced-labor for people who put no effort and/or causes disturbance

If your govt has $6M to fund tourism in Egypt, money to fund opera/ in columbia, comic book in peru, then they have money to help homeless people IN the country. No money should go to non-citizens (let alone non-citizens in another country) while citizens of a country go homeless.

I am typing this from the security of my home, without worrying about 0c temp, or food. So it is easy for me to say this but still, I am sorry that you are going through this, and I sincerely wish you the best; that your life turns around, even if just a little, enough to have a roof over your head.

reply
Thank you for for making this comment. It helped me realize in myself what's changed over the last few years.

I grew up reading Zubrin's The Case for Mars, The Martian, and October Sky. I went to space camp at NASA, and as a 14 year old I sent an angry email to NASA when I learned of the early ISS decommission date(they later extended the lifespan several times, and I like to think I was the reason ;) ).

I followed Bigelow Aerospace in the 2000s doing the only interesting commercial work in space, and afterwards became amongst the first online SpaceX fanboys, long before they ever landed a merlin engine.

I studied hard in school with a passion of going to Embry-Riddle to learn to build rockets - though I ultimately chose a software path in life instead, I stayed an enormous space fanboy over the 2010s, frequenting the SpaceX subreddit and catching every launch and landing stream I could live.

I've cried watching so many rocket landings. The spirit of human endeavor is god damn BEAUTIFUL to me.

I want to point my finger and say that everything else changed. The Internet became what it is. Elon Musk showed his true colors. Software Engineering became middle management.

But the truth is that I've changed.

I care about the people wealth disparity hurts more than I do about us getting our perfect vision of the future now now NOW.

The faster we pump this machine, the louder the Earth is SCREAMING.

The world is on fire, and we're covering it in data centers with the goal of building artificial machines for strip-mining humanity of the very competency in engineering that has given us so much joy.

We're caught up in a race to the bottom and without diverting our path I have to wonder if this starship landing will be one of the last great human-driven engineering achievements before we lose the ability to do so ourselves.

I don't think the answer is to swap the passion for engineering with compassion, as I think they can both live happily together, but I hear where that desire is coming from.

It's coming from a place of love.

And when the last tree has fallen, we may find that we cannot eat money.

May love fill this place.

reply
Thank you for having the courage to post this
reply
ofc a comment like that would get downvoted by investors and technologists, but yes i agree, if you have enough imagination and money, almost anything in engineering is eventually possible. that same imagination and money is rarely spent on making the experience of living beings who are suffering nicer. but we dont live in a 1D world and all people need a win, engineering nerds included.
reply
Semaglutide will likely help on the homelessness front, both directly and by helping us understand deep drives better in general.

Musk's Neuralink is ironically likely to help on the psychiatric disorder side.

Just Send More Money™ is not likely to help (as you recognize). Neither is "compassion".

reply
And a $25,000 EV will alleviate the auto crisis in Americ- wait a minute...!
reply
It is important to recognize what technology will be used for and demand it won‘t be used for evil.
reply
The implied claim being "datacenters are evil"?!
reply
s/evil/a scam/
reply
That ship has sailed since the V2 rocket.
reply
Since the rock and the stick.
reply
That ship has sailed since the first rockets were used to launch bombs and incendiaries somewhere in China, a long time ago. Hammers can be used to build and to kill. Knives cut wood as well as flesh. Humans are belligerent primates whether we want it or not, changing that isn't something even all humanities faculties in the world can manage nor any ideologue intent on creating the New Soviet Man or Übermensch or transhumanist. Fortunately there tend to be more people intent on doing 'good' things with technology than 'bad', where 'good' can also include defending against those doing 'bad' things even though that is a thin line to walk.
reply
Is it? I mean, I’m loving this historic event but if someone wants to remember the stupid parts, what’s wrong with that?
reply
[flagged]
reply