upvote
> [...] nor will they take any action against the reporter.

To be fair, I don’t know for certain whether they will.

However, Lovable was informed weeks in advance. They provided an official statement confirming the findings, which is included in the Handelsblatt article. At no point did they ask us to delay publication or threaten legal action. I can assure you that we would not have published the findings otherwise.

I also want to point out that I contacted Lovable’s head of security directly and shared the results of the analysis: websites, table names, record counts, and an LLM-generated “privacy sensitivity score.” No actual records were shared, as they had already been deleted. He was very cooperative and said his team would review the information and contact the affected customers.

The whole thing was very professional and he was appreciative of our work.

Edit: I see that Igor (Lovable's head of security) has commented in this thread as well.

reply
That's good news for you then.
reply
That may well be so. But that doesn't mean this is how you do it.

I draw the line at downloading data beyond what is required to prove there is an issue and I think you probably should cross that line only when you either have a contract with the company you are researching or if you have a lawyer that you pay that has signed off on what you are about to do. Anything less than that an - imnsho - you are playing the lottery.

Courts, especially in Germany, are typically not pleased if you take possession of the data.

For instance:

https://www.heise.de/en/news/Modern-Solution-Court-of-Appeal...

And quite a few others besides.

reply
This seems to make clear what several other commenters have been pointing to: this isn’t you relating absolute facts of law in the way you've been claiming. It’s you relating your personal ethical evaluation and your opinion about how the laws should be interpreted and followed.
reply
That, and 280 or so company reviews, conversations with compliance officers, CISOs, auditors, pentesters, lawyers and other people in the M&A space about how those companies deal with security issues, reports and what constitutes a potential breach and what does not.

As for the absolute facts of the law: the only law I currently have in mind is the GDPR and that is a surprisingly readable piece of legislation.

reply
So I should expect a news post about Lovable owing GDPR fines for failure to disclose a breach any day now?
reply
Quite possibly. If you are a data subject affected by this affair you can contact your local DPA.
reply