upvote
In France you go on a product and ask the amazon llm to show you its price history.

Is it not possible outside ?

reply
Kind of. This is a new functionality though. And ccc is often more granular.
reply
Thanks for sharing. I’m wondering what your thought on my impression of CamelCamelCamel here and the dependency it has on Amazon’s policies/practices.

CamelCamelCamel is controlled indirectly since it is only allowed to do and report as Amazon permits it via what it does and does not provide in its data feed. Amazon's API does not update in real time or provide all data points. Flash sales, Lightning Deals, and rapid algorithmic price changes often expire before the API refreshes for its inclusion and Camelcamelcamel then actually misses the lowest prices. Amazon's API usually reports the price of whichever seller currently holds the "Buy Box" which its current in court for manipulating via multiple means that may not be legal in various jurisdictions let alone ethical. The exception just pile up here…If Amazon runs out of stock and a third-party seller takes over at an exorbitant price, the chart will show a massive price spike even though the item's standard retail price never changed. The Amazon API reports the public base listing price, and never captures "clippable" green coupon boxes, Prime-exclusive discounts, or checkout promo codes. Third-party sellers frequently delete an old listing (swapping the product altogether) and create a brand-new product ID (ASIN) for the exact same item. This wipes the price tracking history from Camelcamelcamel and starts a new tracking item. Sellers can often edit the "List Price" or "Was" price field on a product, which can trigger inflated MSP price. Marketplace are always messy, but I think we will see that at this scale without adherence to its leadership principles, Amazon is going to find itself more regulated overtime to be more fair to all parties involved, as it’s unable to behave ethically independently and has repeated shown and displayed its inability to do so overtime.

reply
Yes, there are few things that may also not be obvious.

The reason camelcamelcamel still exists is amazon gave them a special permission. Amazon affiliate program which allows CCC monetize their links does not normally allow for price tracking / alerting functionality without special permission from them, and they don't let you store information for more than 24 hours. Amazon API request limits are also pretty low, unless you can drive significant volume, and for a price tracking site, this is essentially catch-22. Without volume, the skus you can track are limited. Even with volume, they still cap you at a number i don't recall right now. They have banned my account as pricetracker.wtf was doing tracking/alerting and i wasn't fully aware of this restriction. I eventually got it unblocked, but had to criple/remove this functionalyt for amazon links, which essentially is the most important thing due to incidential purchases people make on amazon (ie people buy stuff from amazon every 1-2 days, so if they click on a link on your site, that's enough to get some sales from them even if it's not the product they bought).

There was so much I wanted to do on pricetracker.wtf but without amazon, and SEO, it's just not getting enough traffic to make it sensible for me to spend time on.

On the seller side, amazon has strict requirements on pricing, and expect you to price lowest on their platform. You may have direct sale web site, with significantly lower cost, but amazon does not normally let you advertise lower price elsewhere. I follow a seller (creator of brainflakes that you may know) on twitter, he brought this topic up a few times: https://x.com/Molson_Hart/status/2118617556152156408

Overall, amazon is enjoying being a large platform, that's for sure.

reply
Am I in some kind of A/B style test on Amazon.ca? Because I actually see that Amazon itself provides me a price history tool now. I've compared the price history it shows with what camelcamelcamel shows and what Keepa shows and it seems to be accurate.

I don't believe it gives any price history related to third party sellers or the used markets like these other services do, however I personally have found that I almost don't even need 3rd party tools now.

reply
They do have the history, yes. I see it in the US too, but it's not super granular, and timeframe is shorter IIRC.
reply
Yeah it is definitely less granular and harder to see the specifics, however I can go back a whole year. The amount of information given is usually enough to help me decide whether what I am looking at is a good deal or not.
reply
some time ago i was sure of hearing camelcamelcamel went into an acquisition deal with Amazon. but i can't find anything now, either confirming or denying.

and the fact they not only still exist, amazon shows the exact same graph as them, is suspicious

reply
Yeah I can't comment on that aspect, but I do recall they had a deal where in order to be apart of the affiliate program and get the price data they essentially had to agree to only showing price history for Amazon. I guess Amazon has some kind of rule where you can't take their price data and use it to provide comparisons with other retailers.
reply
Yes, this is part of their affiliate program rules. Even more interesting things that restrict what you can do See this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50520371
reply
This doesn't seem to work for shortened Amazon share URLs in the UK. Here's an example: https://amzn.eu/d/090eTeud
reply
Amazon doesn’t allow using its APIs to compare prices across sites so camelcamelcamel is your best bet.
reply
Correct, and not just cross-retailer comparision, they also don't allow you to do price tracking/history in the first place.

https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/help/operating/policies...

https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/help/operating/policies...

reply
Our amazon support is sadly iffy, and it's US only. (see my other comment too).
reply
Very cool website. I got a curiosity, how is this implemented? Do you literally just scrape hundreds of thousands of prices every week?
reply
Affiliate network data feeds. Brands like target, walmart, amazon either have their own affiliate systems or use something like impact.com, cj.com, rakuten to manage them. This way, creators create content for them (posts you see on cnet etc, indie bloggers, or twitter/ig/etc creators) and get compensated for driving traffic.

Often time (not always) as part of joining an affiliate program (like target affiliate program on impact.com) you also get access to their data feed. The feed is usually daily, but sometimes more frequent.

Some others like Walmart + Amazon + best buy have their own api end points (even if they may be using impact for management). When they have an API, it tends to be realtime or close to it

Does that make sense?

reply
Yes, thanks for sharing all that!
reply
Digging the privacy-centric perspective of your site, but perplexed that it then proceeds to only allow Google sign-in...?
reply
I decided not to keep user passwords even in hashed forms, and deal with the complexities of resets etc. and kept my attack surface small.

And given how little traffic I get, I guess it doesn't matter!

reply
Magic link auth instead? Seems popular these days for similar reasons, though the user experience is worse.
reply
FWIW - your "Recent" and "Wishlist" links blow up with a 500 Server Error. Presumably one is supposed to already be logged in when clicking them, but I'm not yet, so kaboom! :)
reply
Yes, I really should fix that hah.
reply