upvote
I read this and was like, hm, I'll test it on myself. Three categories: legit household needs (from either of us), unnecessary junk my wife bought, and unnecessary junk I bought.

I went back in Amazon history until I found the first bit of "junk" I bought (the 3rd thing I bought period, reverse-history wise).

Household: 32

Random junk wife bought: 14

Random junk I bought: 1

The household category is mostly kids' stuff (diapers for the growing baby, underwear for the growing toddler, etc).

So my wife definitely buys more junk. She also definitely buys more real household goods. The ratio of needed things to junk is similar between the two of us (2:1).

reply
“Junk” is a relative term. I suspect your wife would categorize less of her purchases as junk than you would. (Not attempting to say nothing she buys is junk.)

I definitely purchase some actual junk. I also purchase stuff that I could imagine someone else would categorize as junk. e.g. I bought some cheap squeegees for our vehicles. This was not an impulse purchase (researched and debated this for way too long) and I don’t consider them junk. But objectively they are cheap junk, just cheap junk I needed.

reply
My wife bought a floor lamp on Amazon that is the most beautiful piece of furniture I've ever seen. It is above what I would be willing to pay for a floor lamp, but not outrageously priced.

Is that junk spending? To me, it is superfluous. But every time I look at it I think, man am I glad to have that lamp in my living room.

Males can be pretty spartan with their quality of life choices. If it were me I'd order fast food every day because of convenience and cost. But sometimes you have to let your partner elevate your standards even if you don't have those standards yourself.

So my wife spends a lot on amazon, but its probably not a lot compared to her own standards. She is likely proud that she can west elm wife but on an 80% lower budget.

Consumer goods is a mature market, there's targeted audiences personas for every spending level. If you factor in quality of life as well as cost, IMO Amazon has the best cost for value ratio.

reply
Men absolutely hoard and buy crap. They just try to justify it as collecting things, buying stuff to resell later, or part of a new hobby. They go for more expensive purchases: guitar pedals, camping equipment, watches, coffee equipment, handheld gaming devices...

Your comment pretty much just says you married someone with a shopping addiction, and your friends (unsurprisingly) are similar to you and marry the same type of people as you.

reply
This tracks in my relationship. When I first got married, I was at first startled by how often my wife made many small 'frivolous' purchases. I soon realized that I make incredibly infrequent, but huge purchases. I'm sure we could do a cost comparison and point fingers on who is worse, but it doesn't matter because when we are tight on money, we both reign it in, and when we are meeting all of our mutually agreed financial goals, we are more willing to splurge.
reply
> sitcoms

Sitcoms also consistently show that men are fully incompetent so maybe don’t try to cite them as evidence of anything in the real world.

> WIVES

I don’t know. I see lots of guys who buy lots of crap. Anecdotally I also see men buy more expensive things even if the count of things is smaller. “I definitely need to purchase this high end tool for this small task.”

reply
> “I definitely need to purchase this high end tool for this small task.”

Guilty as charged. "Buy once, cry once!" A really nice tool does have a certain satisfaction, even if a bargain basement Harbor Freight tool will often be just as useful. Though I have to say, HF has stepped up their game over the last 5-10 years and has several lines of tools that are legitimately good. More expensive for sure, but very competitive.

reply