I haven't bought anything online besides incredibly niche things (that are usually better bought from a specialty website anyway) in a decade. Where do you live that that's not an option? If you have a Microcenter close to you you are basically guaranteed to live in a large enough urban center that whatever you want is probably available near you. The only thing I can think of that isn't near me (Denver) is retro games, and I just use DKOldies for those.
Part of that wonder was that things just feel a lot bigger to you as a kid. But yes, it was great to have a store with a bunch of toys that didn't also have things like bath towels or over the counter medication
surprisingly, I find Walmart actually still has a good toy section if you're shopping for toddlers and young kids. Unfortunately, boutique kids toy stores are few and far between, I try to support them when I can afford to though.