upvote
Capex and cost of maintenance is definitely something that factors in this kind of decisions, especially for smaller, commercial projects.
reply
All of the above, the nimby opposition is often fierce.
reply
In a desert?
reply
Well, the point of the transmission is to take it from the desert to the places people live.
reply
Yes and neighbors tend not to be a problem in a desert.
reply
Right, but if we're talking about taking energy from the desert to cities, the HV transmission lines we build have to go through a lot of non-desert...
reply
You are still wasting a lot of energy with long distance transmission lines. We are arguing with physics.
reply
It’s as usual a mix of all the issues. Recall that the United States has had essentially flat energy demand for much of the last twenty years or so, so there are no incentives to build new transmission lines.

Also the OP was thinking that the land under the solar panels could be put into better use, but such ultra high voltage transmission lines themselves come with restrictions on what can be built beneath them.

reply
the scale of transmission lines requires large amounts of capital, but also societal buy-in, aka NIMBYs are the problem, at least in western democracies.

Be careful with the term "government nonsense". It's a very slippery slope from there to losing environmental regulations and eventually representative democracy.

reply
Hmmm, very good callout there re: government nonsense. I can definitely see the slippery slope argument, but I look at something like the california high speed rail project and I think "government nonsense" is a good general term for why that has been such a disaster project that is way over budget and way behind schedule. I realize that is a lazy over-generalized use of the term, but I don't know if I agree that characterizing it as a NIMBY problem (which that obviously played a part) solves it. I think it is maybe a frustration with bad processes - processes designed/envisioned with good intentions, but in practice and in combination with a slew of other processes - you get paralysis.
reply
The purpose of a system is what it does.

CAHSR is very effective and spreading money around to a patronage network. Its purpose just isn’t to actually provide high speed rail.

reply
Everything is government nonsense when you think about it. At least we will always have clean, beatiful coal I guess.
reply
As coal burn declines, rising power demand will be primarily met by renewables - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50500905 - November 2026

- Coal’s share of generation will likely decline from 17% in 2025 to 15% by 2027 as 13 GW of capacity is scheduled to retire by the end of next year, EIA said.

Not many coal plants left to go.

https://www.sierraclub.org/coal/coal-plant-map

reply
Thank God for small mercies. I was just being cheeky/bitter about how when it comes to energy, everything is about government subsidies/investment but so far, fossil got so much more.
reply
> China has high voltage lines from their western deserts to eastern cities,

Long lines are AC, they must come from dams or coal generators, still with a huge loss. Solar is DC. It can be transformed at a loss.

reply
China's ultra high voltage grid is DC for long distance transfer from remote western and northern hubs to eastern cities. This uses 24 long lines with 1 at 1100 kV and the rest at 800 kV. It has about 40000 km of lines.

They also have 20+ ultra high voltage AC lines (1000 kV) for shorter region interconnects.

Historically long transmission lines were AC because long lines have to be high voltage to reduce losses¹. Boosting AC voltage for high voltage transmission can be done with a transformer. DC requires more complicated equipment which wasn't really commercially feasible until early this century.

¹Losses are proportional to current. Power is current x voltage. To transmit a given amount of power the higher the voltage the lower the current, and hence the lower the losses.

reply
Thanks for adding some data to this otherwise somewhat vibesy thread.
reply
Look up the Xizang-to-Guangdong UHVDC Project. The whole project build out will have a transmission capacity of 10 gigawatts and has lines stretching from Tibet to Hong Kong.
reply
Long lines are often DC. Talk to an electrical engineer for details, but for long distances DC works better. For distances at the scale of a US state works great, but as you get longer distances DC becomes better again.
reply
> Long lines are often DC.

There are only a few dozen HVDC lines in the USA, so that is inaccurate.

It is far more likely for a NEW long-distance line to be DC compared to the existing installation base.

reply
To briefly describe why:

Current flowing through a conductor produces heat. This scales quadrtatically with the current, and linearly with the resistance. The resistance depends on the cross-sectional area of the conductor and its length. Long wires have more resistance for the same size of wire.

Transformers can raise the voltage & lower the current, or the opposite, in direct proportion.

So you want long-distance transmission to use the highest voltage and lowest current possible, so that the least amount of power is wasted heating up the wires, and so that you don't have to have ridiculously thick wires.

Transformer efficiency rises with frequency. Standard AC grid frequency is quite low, <100Hz everywhere in the world. For small scale utility transformers that's not a big problem, but for transmitting a lot of power the transformer efficiency matters much more. When a transformer heats up that heating happens all throughout it, but heat only dissipates on the surface, so bigger transformers get harder & harder to cool.

Recent (last decade or two) advances in semiconductor design has enabled some really big transistors which can switch a heck of a lot of power very quickly. Switching DC power on & off to create a square wave creates enough changing current that transformers can use it. Transformers don't strictly need AC, they just need changing current through them.

So it ends up being more efficient to convert AC from generators to DC, switch it on & off really fast to create a really high frequency square wave, run that through a step-up transformer designed for that high frequency, and smooth the result out with some big capacitors to clean up the DC. Then that high-voltage DC can be transmitted with relatively low losses on relatively small cables, and go through a similar process to convert down to low(er)-voltage AC at the receiving end.

That wasn't possible until recently, the transistors to switch that much power fast enough didn't exist. Thus the existing grid mostly being AC, with HVDC preferred for new lines.

reply
There are very few really long lines in the US. There are a lot of lines that cross a state or two, but no farther. AC works just fine for those. When you are crossing China, the US (or any continent) DC becomes much better, but most lines are not nearly that long.
reply