upvote
Not sure that multiplying the supply of content that pedophiles jerk it to is a great idea. Not only do you risk exposing people who (hopefully) never would've been exposed to it before, but research shows that increased access to CSAM can actually help normalize the abuse and support deviant behavior in online communities dedicated to it.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11896-023-09611-4

reply
Some have argued the opposite, that "multiplying the supply of this material" further normalises sexual abuse of children, whereas before, it lurked in the shadows of the dark web and was treated like serious contraband, which imbued it with a certain gravity.

Not saying I agree with them, just that this is one of the main points trotted out in support of intrusively policing generation and editing models.

reply
(Recognizing that it's not your argument but responding to it in general)

It's still seen as extremely contraband. We're talking one of the most universal taboos of Western society. Heck, it's equally detested by the US Right and Left. How many things can we say that about?

I don't think anybody is going to suddenly think it's normal, cool, or acceptable to possess or view real or fake CSAM images or to abuse children, just because we aren't prosecuting people for using a diffusion model in a gross way.

reply
I would agree with that, but plenty of campaigners beg plaintively to differ.
reply
The reason why it's a specific problem is in my original comment: Signal to noise ratio.

The huge increase in volume of imagery is impeding operations to rescue children whom are actively being abused or held captive because every image, real or generated, takes up time and resources from the people trying to rescue the _actively abused children_

So your middlebrow refutal ("um ackshually no children are harmed when a diffusion model makes an image" ) of (one of) the many problems with additional CSAM volume is unconvincing and makes me think you've not actually considered the situation in any real detail.

reply
According to your reasoning I'm left wondering, if the synthetic can't be readily distinguished from the genuine then what are you supposing would be the remaining motivation for criminal parties to produce and distribute such things? By producing and distributing they commit a very serious crime and for what personal benefit exactly?
reply