upvote
CMU has some of the best courses on advanced topics, but the ones you have put out so far are the introductory courses. Would love to see courses on advanced topics such as database internals and distributed systems. Also please release materials such as slide decks and PDF course notes.
reply
Andy's database lectures are already all online: start here: https://youtu.be/APqWIjtzNGE?is=1QyZ_p0uYsSGYkN0

I plan to put my distributed systems lectures online the next time I teach it, but not sure when that will be after I rotate out of teaching 15-213. One of my colleagues who also teaches it might do it before then.

reply
Thank you!
reply
actively sitting in the CUC forgetting that my professors are, in fact, people outside of class and do, in fact, also browse HN.
reply
The HN equivalent of seeing your homeroom teacher at the supermarket
reply
Had a teacher stop a class at one point and say “you guys think I’m just, like, the light in your refrigerator, that I just turn off when you walk out of here, don’t you?” - that one stuck with me.
reply
The difference is that on HN the teacher can't see the student's shock and amazement at seeing their teacher in real life. I've been on the teacher's side of such encounters, and the flabbergasted expressions of some (though certainly not all) of the students were a sight to behold.
reply
Hi Phillip, love to see this! I’m a working professional about to finish a Master’s in Cybersecurity Management. I’ve been debating the idea of a PhD on AI security (LLM, agents, NHI, etc). I’d love to see a platform where a working professional can obtain this at their own pace, using LLM for interaction, grading, and guidance, with a human overseeing the progression. I work in higher ed and I see your solution being highly effective at supplementing many of the gaps we currently have in academia. Looking forward to see how this evolves!
reply
seems pretty straight forward to take the content and ask an LLM to build the courseware?
reply
Maybr next year an LLM can supervise a PhD, but we're not there yet.
reply
Really would like to see https://boston.lti.cs.cmu.edu/classes/11-642/ made available
reply
It would be nice if people stopped posting this sort of stuff on YouTube. Or at the very least please cross-post it elsewhere.

YouTube has become very aggressive recently on trying to force you to sign-in, allegedly because its the only way it can "verify you're not a bot" – if you believe that, you believe anything. In reality its just Google being Google looking for ways to track you and add telemetry data.

Even without the "bot checks", I'm sick and tired of the ads and the intrusive pushes to watch other unrelated crap videos.

I just refuse to click on YouTube links anymore.

I've really no idea why people sitll support YouTube for serious videos. People should just leave the place to the Gen-Z content creators posing infront of something making sutpid faces and feigning surprise.

Rant over. :)

reply
Started having way less trouble this year, with ordinary win-10, Chrome, and uBlock Origin Lite. Probably even better with Firefox & uBlock Origin.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UBlock_Origin

reply
Peer tube ftw
reply
Thank you for doing this!

In particular, I would love to see you cover CAD, esp. if you could work up a way to use FreeCAD as the subject.

reply
This. If someone has any recommendations for geometric kernel learning resources, I'd love to hear them.
reply
FreeCAD, & other Linux-centered apps, would be awesome to see in a curriculum.
reply
GP meant “how to write a CAD system”, which is a suitable topic for a CMU course.

Not “how to use FreeCAD”.

reply
I would write a mountain of a paragraph of what this means to me but my immediate response is…

Hell Yeah!!

reply
Makes me wish for more hours in a day to watch
reply
Thank you! CMU grad here! I miss the Panopto platform, I prefer it over YouTube for lectures.
reply
will i get some kind of certificate?
reply
Hi! Love to see these released, thanks to all at CMU who help make it happen. Would y'all be willing to host this on a CMU CS Peertube instance as well versus only on Youtube?
reply
Great idea! We currently have a Panopto server that we're also posting videos to for internal use, and I will look into this as another option.
reply
You could push the videos to CloudFlare R2 and not pay egress fees, and provide an RSS feed for updates. An XML based index of the videos with transcriptions and video markers would be great.

Is your workflow open source? I have had great results building bespoke image editing pipelines using claude and ffmpeg.

It would be awesome to be able to ask an LLM questions and have it respond with lecture snippets.

reply
Thanks so much, I appreciate it. Happy to contribute financially if needed. Also happy to host the instance myself, at my cost, with CMU's permission.
reply
410 or GTFO IMO :p

I do wonder if/how you plan to release supporting materials. The labs made 213 awesome, and LLMs actually do a reasonable job of reproducing the lab itself (I did it for bomb lab for example). But it'd be cool to have a canonical one. I'd love to try malloc again "as an adult."

reply
> mit got here first

Yes, Claude got the silver medal. Bronze still available. It’s yours ;)

reply
Ugh. Claude is so much lower level than an organized course. It’s not even a valid comparison because the professors CREATED theirs. Claude … didn’t really.
reply
I watch CMU database Andy Pavlo's videos all the time. Prbly watched all of them . Big part of my career choice to work in databases.
reply
That's great the school is doing that?

What about the typical math prerequisites, will they also be available or will online learners be expected to know that stuff, before hand?

Will you offer certifications free or will the cost as well?

reply
Non-specialized math is well covered elsewhere.

I wouldn’t be surprised to see more advanced math courses appear. I have gotten a lot of mileage out of the already-published lecture notes from individual CMU professors. (Eg on the foundations needed for statistical learning.)

Math is not going to be an “easy entry level” topic because of the high level of preparation of incoming students at CMU.

reply
Do you/could you release any information about the automation of production work? I'd be interested in what those tools look like and how they're improving your workflow.
reply
It's still very much a work in progress as we scale up for next semester. When things get settled I would love to publish this because it's been a very interesting problem to solve how to present all the different things that can arise in a university classroom. We benefit greatly from having an existing team of course videographers who were previously keeping recordings internal.
reply
[flagged]
reply
Hi Phillip,

In the age of LLMs and Multi-modal models, do you think students across the world will benefit from this? If so, how do you think they will benefit.

For some context, when others released courses in youtube/coursera/udacity decades ago, many students, across the world, did not have any real access good teachers and qualified lecturers who could explain the concepts well. Those releases were boon to them.

Now, we learn by asking AI against anything, include youtube content and AI has been best teacher so far.

reply
> In the age of LLMs and Multi-modal models, do you think students across the world will benefit from this?

Even if your premise is 100% correct, releasing this will still help, because LLMs will ingest it or use it as a source and provide better answers.

reply
These videos, themselves, serve as both grist and ground-truth for inference and agentic interaction.
reply
This is just absolute nonsense and not universal at all.

Just yday I tried testing each frontier llm on questions w.r.t deferred tax and it made up stuff.

Fundamentals should never be learned via llm’s.

reply
Which model did you ask it to?
reply
> I tried testing each frontier llm on questions w.r.t deferred tax and it made up stuff

This would be a stronger example if it were related to Comp Sci. It’s entirely possible that an LLM would perform better on CS fundamentals than details about taxes.

reply
+1. It's surprising that people aren't familiar with hallucinations, even today?
reply
You're going to get flagged for asking - it does seem to be in bad taste IMO - but I do think it is the elephant in the room.

"AI" will teach you anything at a undergrad level - customized to your style.

The real reason you'd go to CMU or MIT is for credentials, or, more honestly, for networking opportunities. That doesn't exist for watching YouTube videos any more than prompting an AI.

reply
What you're really saying is that we need to do more than just post some YouTube lectures. And I agree! More on that front is coming.
reply
Partially true. It's the rigor of the education, the thinking process taught, the caliber of people you work with / meet and especially the office hours with top faculties at CMU is really what at mold you. Not information.
reply
Hard disagree on the reason to attend a school like CMU or MIT (disclaimer, I’m a CMU MatSci PhD)

Networking is a big value proposition, but the biggest benefit IMO is learning what questions are important and learning how to think independently about them. LLMs are great for learning but I don’t think they fully replace the skills you need to ask important questions. (This perspective is probably slanted towards research degrees but I think it’s at least somewhat transferable to engineering)

reply
"AI" cannot teach a person what they don't know they don't know.

Human curation will always have a place in passing on knowledge for people who desire deep understanding of a topic, particularly young people and novices in a field.

reply
You can ask ChatGPT for a detailed listing of all the areas within a discipline and it will give a totally decent answer, better than you'll likely find anywhere else. You can ask it to list disciplines that might be useful, that are taught at university, or whatever.

You can even just ask it "help me know what areas/subjects/topics are useful that I wouldn't even know exist"

reply
On a long enough timeline, we are all dead. In the meantime, come check out Graham Neubig and Daniel Fried teach AI agents, and you will see that we have value still.
reply
You have an amazing dataset, handed out for free by a top rated institution like CMU that can be used as the baseline for whatever learning flow you want to do with your AI.

You do understand that data like this is precisely the goldmine that makes AI good at answering general knowledge questions?

reply
And you probably wonder (if you were the wondering type) why so many are elated at the ongoing collapse of LLM empire.
reply
I'm with you, it's a reasonable question in today's age.
reply
> Now, we learn by asking AI against anything, include youtube content and AI has been best teacher so far.

I don't know who is we besides you, but was it the AI that told you you're being taught well?

reply
And who tells you that a youtube video has taught you well?
reply
My common sense tells me that a college professor is likely to have taught me better than an AI
reply
Common sense around a lot of topics can be misleading. Especially when human bias is taken into account. It's not at all clear to me that a properly trained LLM would not out perform a professor. Even we are talking about known great teaching professors, not average teachers, the LLM has several advantages. It can tailor curriculum to each individual. It can learn and adapt curriculum on the fly which a prof is unlikely to do. It can adjust testing and grading so that the student is maximally engaged. It never misses a day or has a bad day. It can answer questions thoroughly and with as much detail as the student wishes, taking as much time as the student desires. What are the disadvantages?
reply
That it will make up stuff up out of thin air???

And what does properly trained mean, do we know how to "properly train" something with your characteristics?

reply
General common sense tells everyone that not all teachers teach well, and that not all students can learn well from all teachers who may teach well because style preferences may collide. One may easily calibrate an AI to teach them in their preferred style; not so much a college professor.
reply
That's probably wrong, if you know how to use AI well.
reply
Sure, just tell it "don't be wrong"
reply
Make no mistakes.
reply
In this day and age, why learn computer science? I learned to program before there was Google but with AI, someone who doesn't know the difference between an int and a boolean can make a digit thing. Where do you see the importance of big O notation and, say, eating?
reply
Have you ensured you don't make the mistake UC Berkeley did - not providing appropriate accessibility (captions, etc) as required by Federal Law?

Edit: Ouch. It seems I'm being downvoted for being the messenger. Whatever your views of the Berkeley lawsuit and resulting takedown, the Federal law hasn't changed, and any university not complying with the law can end up with the same fate.

reply