upvote
>I know that I've watched Heat before, but I didn't remember the amount of screen time that was spent on somewhat irrelevant personal drama, e.g. Hank Azaria's and Natalie Portman's characters. Those elements felt bolted on and like a distraction.

The last time I watched Heat I followed advice from a friend and skipped past ALL of the personal life stuff (except for Pacino/De Niro's talk) and it was a much better pure heist film. I highly recommend doing it.

reply
> I didn't remember the amount of screen time that was spent on somewhat irrelevant personal drama

I saw Thief and Heat on the big screen recently, which was interesting as I hadn't seen Theif before.

Heat is very clearly Thief++. Beats are very similar, overall plot is nearly the same. In both though he spends a lot of time trying to show where the characters are from in a way to give some reason or motivation, twisted or not, for why they do what they do.

I agree these come across as a bit hamfisted in both, but I do think overall I prefer them in versus cut.

reply
The reason heat and collateral are popular in the self defence community is because in a world of fake action (Hollywood) there are scenes of technical mastery that are exemplars of real world skills. It doesn’t just look cool, it’s good enough to be training examples.
reply
The Collateral scene is not so great tactically. Tom Cruise's character had the drop on both of those guys. He could have just shot the one carrying the briefcase and shot the other if he resisted. Instead, grabbed the gun and did a quick draw while the other guy had also drawn on him. Excellent chance of dying doing this, even if you are an expert.

The Heat bank shootout is also not so great tactically. That sedan was a poor choice as a getaway vehicle vs. a simple white panel van, which would be easier to get into and out of, carry the loot better, and provide visual concealment. Pacino's character's team is also advancing within the field of fire of the police blockade ahead, and thus they are both vulnerable to friendly fire and can't return fire without risking friendly fire upon their team. Yes, Val Kilmer's character's tactical reload, the covering fire tactics, are all great. But the goal of advancing against the police blockade on foot is just wrong. Get through a building, find wheels, escape.

They do exemplify certain skills well, even if it was unnecessary to apply them.

reply
>> popularized in self-defense circles for some reason

Are you referring to Val Kilmer's expert reloading procedure?

reply