upvote
It's actually a great place to go. The idea that people who are attracted to 17 year olds are pedophiles is a corrosive idea. The idea that the reason pedophiles should be punished because they don't love the children is a corrosive idea. They're victories of mindless sloganeering over morality.

The reason that we have an age of consent is to protect people under the age of majority from being used as commodities by adults - to give them a little time before wiser, more powerful people start using them and trading them. It's the same reason why we have laws against child labor.

We don't have an age of consent because it's disgusting to be attracted to 17 year olds, and we don't have legal ages when children are allowed to work because they wouldn't be good workers before then. We do it because children should not be commodities until they've had enough training in this world to be able to defend and represent themselves to some extent. You should be working in a child's interest, they should not be working in yours.

Epstein exploited the girls that were over 18, who were the vast majority, too. They were marginal girls from broken homes who needed money. Making the odd cases when he was connected to 17 year olds the defining characteristic of what happened distorts and trivializes everything. It reminds me how #MeToo ultimately trivialized what Weinstein did by lumping it in with any sort of unwanted sexual advance. I've heard from more than one person that Weinstein went to jail for sexual harrassment. No, he was a serial rapist.

reply
As Judith Levine learned back in her day when she tried to publish "Harmful to Minors", this is an area where nuance goes to die. You're either for "paedophilia" (as defined by whoever's standing in front of you after having considered the matter for a few milliseconds), or against.
reply
IMO there's far more harm being done by 'think of the children' laws than pedophelia has ever done. We've reached the point where people don't give a f*ck about children.
reply
It's difficult to weigh those things, and I'm not an empirical researcher in this area. My gut sense, though, is that genuine paedophilia is quite rare, while the harms of thought policing and censorship are all too vivid and acutely present in the every day.
reply