upvote
Does it matter? Let's keep at it for a while and see if it continues.

Though I imagine they're pretty certain whether it's one or the other. Teachers at least seem to be quite certain, though 'common sense' doesn't always pan out.

reply
> Does it matter?

Yes, it is important to understand which things are true and which are false.

reply
True, but probably not enough to delay implementing a policy that seems to be giving small but noticeable improvements across the board.
reply
Its a stretch to call them “noticeable improvements across the board”. The study barely found statistically significant results when excluding students with significant changes and combining subjects. Math and reading on their own had no significant results and neither did including students with extreme changes.

They also ignored other changes that may have been introduced by schools at the same time.

From a policymaker perspective, I’d argue that this study falls short of warranting investments into these pouches.

One may even argue that there is a bit of a conflict of interest here with some of the data for the study coming from the manufacturer themselves and the study specifically discussing these pouches as opposed to other ways of enforcing such ban…

reply
My anecdata from my teacher connected friends and family is that the COVID cohort is just that - a cohort where effects are somewhat contained to those who went through it, so you can sort of watch those kids grow up / trace effects to those who studied and socialized during COVID.

I'd assume you could sort of untangle that cohort's success from all students, some of whom are now ditching their phones for the first time without any COVID disruption

reply
Its been like 4 years. We can stop blaming COVID for everything.
reply
For kids no. As a music educator we're still seeing a real gap in kids who are now between 10-16 who didn't get the opportunity to pick up a school instrument during the covid years. The impact on something like this filters through the system, it doesn't just go away because it's been 4 years.
reply
I don't see people "blaming COVID", a coronavirus with no agency, for anything.

I see people, including the person to whom you are responding, continuing to make observations about policies which were put in place during the pre-endemicity phase of the spread of that coronaviruses, some of which have turned out to have caused far more harm than the little or zero good they did (school-closures being perhaps the most obvious).

reply
Were the New Zealand school closures more harmful than helpful?
reply
Yes, by a lot.

Given that school closures had no helpful impact at all, any harm makes them more harmful than helpful.

They were not only harmful in second-order effects, such as delayed educational milestones and delayed access to care, but also in first-order effects, as they caused spread to occur across generations in households to the high-risk tier, instead of stratified spread across the low-risk tier.

If there's one lesson from this pandemic, at least with regard to respiratory pathogens for which advanced age is associated with higher risk of morbidity and mortality, it's that school closures are unambiguously detrimental, with significant harms observed and no measurable benefits.

This study is specific to New Zealand, since that's what you asked, but the same results have been observed everywhere on earth:

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jpc.15551?af=R

reply
Counterpoint: We still have lots of covid going around, sometimes cases last for many months. Its negative cognitive affects are gonna keep showing up in the data and preventing meaningful comparisons with before. It was a step change, not an isolated event.
reply
The lockdown had permanent strongly negative impact on every kid that was in school at that time. You’d need to wait for all of them to be out (about 15 years) to safely stop blaming it.
reply
There's also the possibility of tests being dumbed down even further, like they have been doing steadily for the past 40 years.
reply
Not all countries had widespread school lockdowns, but all countries have the same phone problem.
reply