upvote
I understand what you're saying, but I can also understand why those replying are upset by it. The HN guidelines ask us to avoid flamebait, and this kind of comment – taking a topic that carries a deep emotional charge for people - and reframing it simply as a matter of data and statistics, qualifies as flamebait. I can understand you didn't mean to upset people. But I'm posting this as a reminder to everyone to try to avoid this style of commenting on touchy topics. We're all humans here and our emotions about topics like this are valid, especially when harm to children is involved.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

reply
> [..] taking a topic that carries a deep emotional charge for people - and reframing it simply as a matter of data and statistics, qualifies as flamebait.

I cannot disagree with this point more strongly.

If anything in the parent comment constitutes flamebait, it's the dismissive opening:

> School shootings aren't a concern.

But soberly offering data on topics people are emotional about is not flamebait, it's simply discourse.

(Not that it matters, but my wife is an elementary school teacher and we have children in school, so this is as about as sensitive a topic as it gets for me.)

reply
Parent's aren't worried about school shootings because they're mathematically a concern, parents are worried because they're emotionally terrifying. People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.
reply
> People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.

I'd wager you could walk into any PTA meeting in the country and start reading off the hazards from the material safety data sheet for dihydrogen monoxide and get the majority of parents to sign off on a ban.

I agree people are horrible at evaluating risk. They're even worse when they're evaluating risk involving dangers they do not understand. The problem is compounded even further when it involves their babies. And yes, it doesn't matter if their baby is 17 years old, it's still their baby in their heart & eyes.

reply
Part of this is a sign of the times. I am not one to view the past through rose-tinted glasses, but pop psychology and what not have normalized coddling and indulgence. As someone once said, it's not the strong who are dangerous, but the weak.
reply
This only further reinforces the argument that lack of access to phones is not a safety concern.
reply
Policy decisions should definitely be based on statistics and not feelings though, and "pointing at some numbers" is a great way to structure a disagreement about policy.
reply
School boards are elected, and highest turnout for those is going to be among parents. If a majority of parents have a concern then the school board has to listen if they want to keep their position.
reply
You're talking about the difference between effective leadership and pandering, yes.

But stats + "these policies will harm your children" and "they will not reduce the risk of an already improbable event" is the correct choice.

And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

reply
You're absolutely right, but imagine being the school board member who wants to be reelected. You either have to convince a bunch of concerned parents to reason about something they didn't reason their way into, or you have to disregard the parents' wishes and know you'll lose your seat.

I wish more elected officials at least attempted the former, but populism seems to work. As hard as it is, I'm more bullish on educating the electorate than getting elected officials to act against their incentives.

>And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

Yeah I think most people here are agreeing with you and we're just arguing about how things work vs how we wish they worked. Governance would look very different if HN was representative of the electorate, but it's not.

reply
> Governance would look very different if HN was representative of the electorate, but it's not.

It would be equally awful, just in a slightly different way. :)

reply
Benevolent dictatorship under @dang is the solution to the world's problems.
reply
This view-- gotta get reelected-- encapsulates the sorry state of the GOP and democratic party establishment today, and perhaps explains why they're perpetually surprised when actual principled candidates win.
reply
actual principled candidates are maybe 50/50, even in an environment like this. So many people will still bet on a coin flip if it means they can keep doing what they are used to.
reply
>And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

So as effective as campaigning to Gen Z, who statistically do not turnout to polls as much.

reply
This simply makes statistics a new vector through which opinions are relayed. It is incredibly easy to tweak statistics, questions etc in a way to bias the result towards what you want. This is a major issue in the social sciences for instance
reply
Sometimes feelings turn into statistics (eg anxiety, depression, etc). You can't always just tell people to walk it off. Sometimes you can, but sometimes it absolutely has to be handled (gun control).
reply
But you can tell people to seek help. Being neurotic is treatable.
reply
help? In this economy? People can barely afford groceries, let alone mental health proffessionals.
reply
Goddamnit.
reply
Of course, but if that were always the case, there wouldn't be so many guns out there for this to be an issue in the first place ;-)
reply
[flagged]
reply
Arguing in bad faith is fun! But you are right: We should allow an entire generation of kids to suffer from phone-induced brainrot so that their parents don't have to worry about school shootings.
reply
Or… maybe we do something about access to guns?

Or if a minor commits a murder with a weapon, the parent gets punished.

Or maybe we take a look at why people are shooting up schools.

Or maybe we do all three because we have a lot of people in government and we can check more than one thing at a time.

reply
> Or… maybe we do something about access to guns?

Arguing this point on the basis of something less likely than being hit by lightning smells of bad faith and exploiting tragedy for political ends.

Maybe gun access should be restricted but it is not on this basis. We are well into the point of "diminishing policy returns" with an event whose incidence is well below 0.1/100k, and ranks in deadliness far below other much more manageable risks.

There is a strong case to make that the intersection of juvenile phone usage, social media, and sedentary lifestyles is far more deadly than gun usage, and that discussion not politically hamstrung by such petty things as "the constitution".

reply
I was a teacher’s pet level good kid and I stopped worrying about school shooting in the eighth grade. Why?

Because I noticed that the school lunch kitchen door was propped open before lunch hour, and that the soup pots were just inside the door and anyone could just drop rat poison in there and it would be mayhem.

Guns are a convenient tool of violence but I experienced that already on the regular, and there are so many ways to hurt people even if you’re not the strongest person there.

reply
Sure. Thing is

1) Most kids (especially those who'd do this) aren't that smart and all encompassing

2) the kinds of kids doing school shootings are not ones who'd take long term malicious joy out of slowly killing their student body. They have specific targets in mind and want to see their anguish now (collateral is just that)

3) there's the social media influence of it all. In some ways a school shooter wants to eventually be identified and glorified. Getting away with murder on the down low would not satisfy that need.

4) A school body is in more direct control of a safety concern like an open door than checking the content of every student's bag.

reply
In addition to the other comment pointing out this is an emotional issue, it doesn't help that on average, at least 3 - 5 times a year our local schools go into lockdown because of some reported threat or another. Every time it happens, WhatsApp groups light up with parents feverishly checking in and reporting the latest updates. These schools forbid phones during class, but that doesn't stop parents from trying to text their kids.

It's always out of "an abundance of caution" of course, but no person responsible, in case an incident does happen, is going to go up there and recite these statistics.

reply
> at least 3 - 5 times a year our local schools go into lockdown because of some reported threat or another

There is a reasons that doctors do not casually suggest tests for e.g. all sorts of cancers when those tests carry false positives: false alarms can, in aggregate, be worse than the event they aim do detect.

The mentality that "bad thing could happen" --> "we must act" is deeply embedded in our culture, but is incredibly harmful. Sometimes the best course is to make an informed decision to accept the risk, because all available alternatives are worse.

reply
reply
I'm struggling to derive an actual point or refutation of my comment, from the provided link.

Statistical presentations like that which do not quantify the actual harm ("how many were injured / killed") and instead focus on the emotional aspect ("how much did a scary thing happen") are not worth discussion; they're intended to mislead or frame the discussion in dishonest ways.

* How often does the thing happen

* What are the harms / costs of the thing

* What are the available responses, what risk reduction do they represent, and what burden / cost do they incur

reply
It's not just deaths, all kids stuck in the school during the lockdown are affected significantly
reply
People are afraid of whatever they are told to be afraid of in the media. It's not about numbers and probabilities.
reply
> School shootings aren't a concern. Just picking a random year from google-- there were 21 school shooting deaths in 2023.

That’s some normalisation of deviance you got going on there.

There should be zero school shootings.

However, being able to contact your kid directly because they’re carrying a phone isn’t going to render them any less shot.

reply
There should be zero school bullying too, and as often as not the perpetrators of school shootings have not been having an okay time at school.
reply
We should have zero deaths from falling off roofs, or getting struck by lightning, yet those happen more than school shootings.

I propose government mandated safety rails with hazard-yellow paint on all roofs and personal taxpayer-supported lightning rods.

More seriously and on-topic, depression and anti-social behavior are far bigger risks to teens and phone usage makes that risk far worse without meaningfully affecting shootings. Can we get rid of phones?

reply
[flagged]
reply
How is this inhumane? Because it calls attention to the scourge of vehicular child killing? The bloodbath on the highway? Can you not admit there's something curious in the way people selectively care about things regardless of their importance or solveability?
reply
That number should be 0. As a parent of a child in a country that doesn't have issues with school shootings, the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age, aren't allowed to wear light-up shoes to not be seen too easily by a shooter, some states even argue that teachers should carry. This is very concerning to me. Enough that I would not choose to move to the US for fear of the safety of my kids. Arguing that kids die from other causes too diminishes the urgency of the situation, which I understand is your point, but you might want to reconsider.
reply
<Edit>I agree it should be zero!, and....</Edit>

Diminishing urgency is not the charge this puts upon gun control activists. One should really be asking why people fail to prioritize addressing the greater child killers. I don't think it's necessarily because this one is more addressable. Activists who make this their main concern primarily seem to want large scale firearm seizure. Even in an authoritarian's dream America where the Constitution is a wax tablet for carving and molding we would struggle to take peoples' guns. I hope I am not extrapolating too much.

reply
> the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age...

...is due to a toxic media culture that latches onto particular issues more over their political exploitability than for their actual impact on threats to life / liberty.

If media / politicians truly cared about kids they'd have instead spent their energy over the last decade campaigning against

- Food policies that encourage junk food even (especially) among lower income families

- School policies that allow or encourage technology despite the near zero evidence for benefit and numerous studies showing harm

- School permissiveness towards (or approval of) phone use and social media despite mountains of evidence for harm

One can say that we should reduce the shootings to zero, but it would be folly to let that prevent tackling far larger, more tractable issues that are not politically divisive as "gun control" is. I can already anticipate the angry responses over the recognition that it is a divisive issue; surely that itself is demonstrative of the folly?

reply
You’re way more likely to get hit by a car crossing the street.
reply
[flagged]
reply
Because it ignores a completely solvable problem.

And number of deaths is not the whole story. Entire generations of children are coping with school shootings. From in-school drills to metal detectors. We are in a position of having to teach all kids about avoiding being murdered. That comes with a cost. Both in dollars and emotional impact that will shape the rest of their lives.

So yeah. 21. But those 21 have a huge impact.

It’s no surprise the same people who want to take education apart are the same people that want to do nothing about school shootings which make schools danger zones.

reply
> And number of deaths is not the whole story. Entire generations of children are coping with school shootings. From in-school drills to metal detectors. We are in a position of having to teach all kids about avoiding being murdered. That comes with a cost. Both in dollars and emotional impact that will shape the rest of their lives.

So why do we have to do that now, and did not have to do that in 1980? IIRC, in 1980, you could buy guns at K-Mart (the Walmart of the day).

I posit that this is at its core a media problem: it creates the fear and basically advertises murder to maladjusted kids. You'd probably have a lot less of them if they got very little coverage when they did happen.

reply
You don't have to go as far as 1980. You could buy guns and ammo at Walmart well into the 00s.
reply
I agree 100% with OP and I am a parent of two young kids in school. I'm a logical person and while it is hard to suppress emotional responses to hearing about trafficking, school shootings, etc, it's important to think logically about the risk.

Should we try to mitigate school shootings, et. al.? Yeah. Are people fixing the issues? no. They point to guns. Yes, guns are used, but the problem is mental health. No one gives an eff about your family. Everyone cares about what effects themselves.

It's starts at home. Kids become isolated, parents are busy working and do notice or care or are able to intervene, faculty don't have the means or care to address issues at school (bullying, etc). It's not the gun's fault. It's the layers of failures up to that point.

Anyway, people should be more afraid of inattentive drivers, walking alongside roads at night, etc.

reply
One wonders how many of the parents who've insisted their kids need phones because of school shootings are perfectly happy to drive them back and forth while frequently staring at their own phone and in traffic plagued with people doing the same thing.
reply
deleted
reply
[flagged]
reply
Yes, in fact, my kids go to school not too far from a school where a major shooting happened (i.e. you'd recognize the name of the school if I mentioned it), and I just never worry about school shootings at all. Heck, they're at school right now.

I'm also one of the parents that doesn't feel any need to be able to text/call them at any time of the day. I'm raising them to be able to handle themselves and contact me through means available to them if they need to.

Modern parenting gets a lot wrong in my opinion.

reply
Modern society is plagued with misplaced worry. I blame democracy.

Someone worries about school shootings and they do things around it. But not everyone needs to nor even should worry about them, as it becomes counterproductive.

reply
deleted
reply
Is my answer in any way relevant? Or is it just an attempt to shift the discussion to an emotional one or build an ad hominem?
reply
[flagged]
reply
[flagged]
reply
I understand why the comment was upsetting and I've replied to the commenter. But comments like this are clearly against the guidelines, no matter who or what you're replying to. Please don't reply to a bad comment with another bad one. It's what generates flamewars, and that's exactly what we're trying to avoid here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
reply