upvote
Sure, my age range is 2 to 7.

Some parents genuinely send a 4 year old to pre-k with an iPad or an iPhone.

Those kids cant sit still, spend every moment they're allowed to on the phone, and have groups of 5+ kids crowded around them trying to watch too at recess or lunch or after care.

No damn pre-k kid needs a phone at school. If you want to discuss whether access is appropriate for someone in their late teens, sure, that can be a more nuanced discussion.

But for anyone under 12? No.

Anyone under 15? Probably not.

A teen with a driver's license? Maybe yes.

And sure, phone addiction is in no way limited to those kids, so maybe you and I should consider "banning" then for certain times too ( we do this already - no phone evenings ).

But school admin and teachers need clear and enforceable boundaries that let them remove electronic devices in these cases.

You can't leave it to case by case because then teachers can't effectively police it without it becoming career threatening and not worth the effort (one parent who takes offense can make your life hell, and threaten your job).

So I'm all for the bans. I think it's healthy even if it doesn't impact grades directly.

reply
You're entitled to your opinion, but that's not really evidence. I'd tend to agree that younger kids don't need phones, but teens get a lot of value from them. The same kind that adults get. My oldest was using her phone in school regularly for school activities. Kids can get distracted by anything. I could doodle or stare out the window or pass notes in class as much as my boredom dictated.
reply