upvote
The term "safety" (also cf. "violence") has become extremely abused in the modern discourse. From what I can tell, the modal reason to "feel unsafe" nowadays is hearing an opinion the complainant deems unacceptable to hold, or the physical presence of a person the complainant associates with such thought (assuming that said person belongs to a group that is socially acceptable to target).
reply
Same goes for abuse, assault, violence, and trauma. They've all been perverted way beyond their normal meanings.
reply
We also seem to be living in a time for unencumbered abuse though. The narrative you present also makes it more difficult for actual victims to speak out loud though; it is easy for people with narcissistic traits to employ the narrative to guilt trip their targets to thinking they are delusional, prolonging traumatic situations using gaslighting.

We need language that can accommodate both human vulnerability and human disagreement without confusing the two. Otherwise, we end up with two equally damaging outcomes. Ordinary disagreement becomes pathologised, while genuine abuse becomes harder to identify and articulate.

reply
The misuse of those words is insulting to those who have experienced actual trauma, violence, etc. and dilutes the conversation around real suffering and oppression.
reply
How is the potential for abuse more common or less encumbered now than any time in the past?
reply
[dead]
reply
This is definitely the case. We've conflated physical safety with emotional and mental safety, and while I think it's okay to use the word safety to describe all three, they're radically different things. Physical safety is paramount, and because of this, people want to use the phrase "safety" as sort of a thought-terminating cliché to get people to change their behavior.
reply
People do this with all powerful words. They see how effective a word or a label can be in shutting down conversation, changing behavior, etc. And they say, "If only I could use that term in situation X, too, in order to get what I want." And so they expand the definition of word. And expand it, and expand it, until it applies to basically everything. Which is extremely frustrating in the interim, because it's an abuse of the word. But the word gradually loses its power as a result. Which is relieving because the abuse ends, but also frustrating because it was (in its original form) quite useful.

You see this with a lot of the -ism and -phobic words. For example, by 2020, it was common to hear even the most liberal of people saying things like, "Everyone is racist." Whereas 20 years before that, to successfully brand someone a racist could have ended their career.

reply
One of these I always find most revealing, perhaps because it’s slightly less political than other examples, is homeless.

When an ordinary person here’s the word homeless he immediately thinks of a person sleeping on the street. But the government / activist term is far far broader. It’s intended to tie larger issues of affordability into the very publicly salient issue of people living on the street.

reply
Ok, now try to say this publicly without loosing your job and/or being acid-attacked by some activist.
reply
A lot of those "opinions the complainant deems unacceptable to hold" are things that actually are unsafe, like believing that the complainant deserves to be the recipient of violence. If someone tells you they believe you should receive violence, and you feel unsafe, that is not some sort of anxiety issue, that is a rational reaction.
reply
> like believing that the complainant deserves to be the recipient of violence.

As far as I can tell, the overwhelming majority of complaints made on this basis are simply completely invalid, claiming a "belief" that is not even remotely supported by evidence. There is, if anything, far stronger evidence of such "beliefs" among those successfully weaponizing the "I feel unsafe" claims.

reply
Not really. If someone says “when the revolution comes people like you are going to be the first ones up against the wall” it satisfies your condition that the person is telling you that you should receive violence. But unless you believe “the revolution” is imminent and this person is going to play a leading role, there’s not much reason to feel unsafe. Uncomfortable perhaps, but not unsafe.
reply
You should feel unsafe around that person. They are telling you they want to see you dead.
reply
Well, maybe if we did something to prevent the kids from being shot, the parents wouldn’t think that was so important.
reply
It's a price they're willing (for us) to pay
reply
See also fearing the predictable consequences of their own actions.
reply
Many safety issues are actually anxiety issues.

IMO school shootings are unfortunately part of this equation. If the school can’t protect your children then you’re going to feel more anxious and want direct contact with them.

reply
The irony is that the real world social isolation and online dark socialization from constant phone use seems to have been a factor in a lot of recent school shootings.

The sort of detachment from reality and radicalization across distance you see in the Tumbler Ridge text messages is way less likely to happen if kids’ time is filled up with physical human connection.

reply
> The irony is that the real world social isolation and online dark socialization from constant phone use seems to have been a factor in a lot of recent school shootings.

It's the opposite actually. Kids that are depressed drift into social media. Usually starts in the none other than family.

reply
I don't get the connection; Columbine predated most kids having cellphones, and after that we had a steady stream of shootings during the early to mid 00s when cell phone ownership among kids became common, but nonetheless phone bans were the default norm and strictly enforced during this period.

It seems that it was only when cellphones became smartphones that parents started sperging out about the bans.

reply
I think it started when the parents themselves got addicted to smartphones, and thus to the expectation of constant communication.
reply
I think social media also significantly increased anxiety levels of parents.
reply
I recall kids lining up at the school office to check in on their parents on 9/11. It wouldn't have made any material difference to the emergency if those kids had cell phones instead.
reply
I think Sandy Hook, which happened in 2012, caused the reaction of "my kids need this in order to tell me they're safe."
reply
This is Horror Movie 101 though. You start beeping your child’s phone while they’re being stalked and they’re the first to die. This is more anxiety by the parents. Thinking information is control. It is not. Many kids have trouble following strange directions from parents in the first place, and that is a legitimate anxiety parents have even with a hand on their child. Which is also Horror Movie 102.

If I see a bear or an active shooter and tell my child to shut the fuck up, will they shut the fuck up or argue with me about being mean or bossy?

reply
The US has Amber, etc, Alert. I wonder if anyone's asked the GSM consortium for a new type of cell tower alert broadcast that would put phones in the area on silent, to prevent them beeping and be homing beacons for bullets.

What would be a good color for this alert? (although Amber Alert's name comes from a kidnapped child named Amber).

This comment written with a lot of tongue-in-cheek.

reply
infrared alert.
reply
TBF the problem relative to when I was a kid is that there used to be pretty widespread pay phones. Now they are very rare.
reply
When there is school shooter, it's much safer to call police/parent from your own phone then going to Dean office and looking for a phone.
reply