upvote
>Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

reply
I'm not sure why this rule exists. Calling out antipatterns might be the best way to resist them.
reply
I think the point here is that saying HN is becoming Reddit is itself an antipattern.
reply
If HN 'becomes reddit' YC can make a lot of cash.
reply
I wouldn't necessarily compare it to Reddit, since that's a tired trope, but there seems to be a significant lack of attention to nuance lately, and heavy on speculation, often wild.
reply
Yes it seems like a new cohort or two have come on over the past 2-3 years and changed the tenor of the conversation. It's hard to say definitively - I wonder if somebody with access to the whole corpus of comments over time could do an analysis.
reply
With these big outages, there are so so so much fewer solid facts to hold on to when talking about them.

We get stories about what went wrong filtered through journalism that doesn't have the technical knowledge to convey it accurately. So even if they get the real story straight from the source, we get an inconsistent version of the story that sounds somehow off.

Which leaves all kinds of room for conspiracy, preconceptions, or prejudices.

reply
Was thinking the same thing! The quality of commentary on this page is absolute dross. I might as well be on the R-word website. What is going on?
reply
And Reddit has become like 4chan.

Circle of internet life.

reply
What did 4chan become like?
reply
I hate to be that guy but this is apparently an HN trope that you’re describing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1524184
reply
the bigger question is why are you on Reddit in the first place
reply
Very true. It is an bot-managed (infested) engagement engine, not a credible source for most things any more. They are driving the narratives that they need in order for them to keep eyeballs on the site. I found this job listing [0] under "Computer Gigs" sidebar for the Dallas Craigslist. I suspect that there are similar opportunities all over the country.

[0] https://www.craigslist.org/view/d/dallas-dallas-redditors-ge...

Reddit is done. I'm so glad I got perma-banned by their AI mod. Though the meat-space mods lifted the ban on appeal, I had a long enough interval that I unwound all engagement. I found reddit right after they launched and have spent a lot of time over the last 20 years on various subs. That's all over now.

reply
Because it's where all the interesting discussion happens once you unsubscribe from the default subs
reply
It’s still excellent for porn.
reply