upvote
What does this mean for what is arguably the most famous data-anecdote gap: crime rates? People have been thinking crime has been skyrocketing for decades (well before the pandemic), but statistics show the opposite?
reply
People - the "individuals" - really dislike being victims of crime. There's also the broken windows theory: a crime, especially when it goes unpunished, sends a signal to every actual or potential criminal: "Here, you can do as you please."

So, yes, I almost agree with the statement "People have been thinking crime has been skyrocketing." IMO, we're never necessarily far from a situation in which widespread impunity could cause crime to escalate rapidly.

reply
Very simple: the news is not anecdotal; the news is editorial. If you were to talk to people about their own direct experiences with crime, I am confident that the aggregate anecdotes would look far more like the crime stats. Instead, you have in news media an industry that chooses what to cover, and it never covers: "this part of town had no crime today," which is an anecdote itself. Thus, because the news is biased (towards something rather than nothing) in what it reports, and because most people believe the news as an accurate representation of the world, this malforms their view of the world.
reply