upvote
So many unfalsifiable vague-ass conspiracies on this board.

Everyone sees the incompetence of the Trump admin. Everyone sees things like this highly classified network breaking and the Signal leaks -- it's not out of character or anything. But when it comes to "pre-programming" the population, the powers that be suddenly turn hyper-competent.

reply
To be a bit of devils advocate, propaganda/marketing has been a top US field for a long time now and its tactics and methods and efficacy have never stopped improving.

That said IMO our organizational structures, both private and governmental, are far less competent than anyone wants to believe and these kind of problems were only a matter of time. You don't get government contracts or billion dollar deals by giving realistic timelines or proper estimates of capabilities, you get them by blowing smoke up somebody else's ass and offering the impossible.

Masterlock for example isn't a leading lock manufacturer by producing good and secure locks, they are just good at pretending they are because most people don't actually test or know how to test them. And then people act surprised when some 15 year old gives one a swift kick and it pops right open. It wasn't secure by virtue of nobody kicking it until then, nobody just bothered to try before.

reply
>To be a bit of devils advocate, propaganda/marketing has been a top US field for a long time now and its tactics and methods and efficacy have never stopped improving.

Eh, I don't buy it.

"Fast forward eight decades, and [US] government messaging efforts like FDR’s are basically nonexistent. At some point during those eight decades, Americans collectively concluded that this sort of message is propaganda — the kind of thing the Nazis and the Soviets did — and is therefore represents the kind of government thought control that a free society should desperately avoid. We decided it was best for the government to step back from the fray of public opinion, guarding the principles of free speech from an Olympian remove, and letting the best ideas prevail in a neutral Marketplace of Ideas. That approach seemed to do fairly well for us in the late Cold War."

From https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/liberalism-is-losing-the-infor...

See also https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/how-to-take-our-country-back

And https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48628832

The mysterious "pervasive US government propaganda" is sort of like the invisible dragon in Carl Sagan's garage.

reply
If regular people are not allowed to run their own AIs, this will be worth about 100 trillion dollars to the people who already have a lot of power. I can understand why conspiracy theories form.
reply
Nobody is alleging conspiracy, just that enough incentives align to produce comparable outcomes.
reply
The people that run the NSA are non-partisan careerists.

Keeping telling yourself Trump has any say in how their organization functions at an operational level. I think Trump is incompetent but I dont think that incompetency travels down to the operational level in intelligence like you think, the politicans trust these guys to do their jobs with their expertise.

You can call people conspiracy theorists all you want as an insult (thats what it is), or you could just try have an analytical understanding of the past and how these institutions operate.

reply
This was true until DOGE caused chaos across the government. I've worked for the government as a contractor and civilian employee, and the chaos of DOGE is still affecting tons of organizations. You don't just bounce back from losing a huge percentage of your workers, huge funding cuts, and dip shits given control of your organization.

Trump's admin and Republicans own much more of any government failures because of DOGE, and they will for awhile. But, sadly, they are still trying to blame the previous admin, but seems like most people are no longer buying it.

reply
Sure, Mr. Righteous. Let's not do anything about the billions of dollars funding transgender mice studies and overseas ideological movements.
reply
>Keeping telling yourself Trump has any say in how their organization functions at an operational level.

"CIA Employees’ Names Risk Exposure After Trump Demands List in Unclassified Email"

https://www.newsweek.com/trump-unclassified-email-cia-agents...

What would falsify your theories?

The thing about them being "nonpartisan careerists", at least, appears to be false. See https://steadystate1.substack.com/

Same for "the politicans trust these guys to do their jobs with their expertise". See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UD6F4F-Bcw

So roughly speaking your claims seem to fall into two categories: (a) unfalsifiable, or (b) falsifiable, and additionally false. If your falsifiable claims are false, I expect the same is likely true of your unfalsifiable claims.

>You can call people conspiracy theorists all you want as an insult

How do you explain, for example, people who insist that the earth is flat despite all evidence to the contrary? There's clearly a cognitive trap around conspiracies which a lot of people fall into, and I'm supposed to avoid mentioning it when it comes up, in order to be polite? No thanks.

What does Occam's Razor say? https://substack.com/@kryptogal/note/c-390204515

reply
Did you really link a video from. The fake grifter CIA guy?? That guy is like the course seller of spy youtube. Completely lacking any credibility and has been called out by dozens of people for probably lying about all his experience.

Im talking about the NSA anyways, I can assure you the NSA is very scientific and an apolitical institution. Much closer to NASA than it is the CIA.

Why are you comparing me to a flat earther.. You're too irrational and judgemental to even have a discussion about this. You're one of those people who has to be the anti-skeptic, its kinda cringe rationalist speak where you think the world is black and white.

Im not going to argue with someone who resorts to these tactics to discredit someones argument just because they dont like their takes.

reply
Just want to point out, the guy absolutely worked at the CIA, what he did at the CIA is where the questions come in.

And yes, even the NSA isn’t immune to the political bullshit coming out of the Trump administration.

Personally, as someone who worked on these types of systems for 12 years, I don’t blame the Trump administration in this case as far as doing something directly to cause it like a budget cut….

However, this administration created an insanely toxic culture. I saw many many talented people leave due to the toxicity that grew purely due to the administrations choices.

There has absolutely been a brain drain in govt agencies.

reply
"When [civil servants] wake up in the morning, we want them to not want to go to work, because they are increasingly viewed as the villains. We want their funding to be shut down. . . . We want to put them in trauma." - Russell Vought, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget
reply
[dead]
reply