upvote
This take is boring and uninformed.

You could use this logic about any topic that doesn't directly affect every single citizen in a way they recognize.

Not every person needs to know or cares to know about every news event. But that doesn't mean the news shouldn't be reported.

Also, those of us who lived through Sept 11 and the failure analysis + Patriot Act know that the federal government has a "secret network". The reason Sept 11 was successful is because our "secret network" knew about suspicious activities of the 19 hijackers but didn't have any way to message the domestic law enforcement (the non-secret comms networks of the US) to surveil them.

reply
> The reason Sept 11 was successful is because our "secret network" knew about suspicious activities of the 19 hijackers but didn't have any way to message the domestic law enforcement (the non-secret comms networks of the US) to surveil them.

Phone lines were still operating. What exactly stopped them from just calling local law enforcement and saying "These guys look like they might be trouble, I can't get into a lot of details, but can you maybe keep an eye on them?"

reply
deleted
reply
> but didn't have any way to message the domestic law enforcement … to surveil them

Isn’t this more usually stated in bald terms like “no communication across silos”, just like in corporate America?

reply
That's how Congress people tried to communicate how it worked before Sept 11.

But the classified system is still a silo, so all of the changes didn't fix anything according to that analogy.

There were more complicated changes (FISA Court, unclassified tags on classified records, Fusion Centers, Suspicious Activity Reports, etc).

reply
It’s not about the specifics. The public and especially other parts of the government would be interested in confirmation that a part of the government can or cannot operate as normal.

Likewise, nobody gives a shit about Juniper routers in Arkansas but they sure as hell care if the FAA can’t operate.

reply