upvote
Workers create wealth for owners to extract. Your friend was creating so Musk could extract.
reply
That worker is way more replaceable than Musk.
reply
In a sense, yes of course. That has zero relevance to the comment you're replying too though. How much a person is paid for the value they produce does not necessarily correspond to how easy it might be to replace them.
reply
[flagged]
reply
No, the comment you are replying is right at its core. What you did (added 'is hence a parasite') is childish and amateur.

The owner can only extract and be a parasite, or can guide and reinvest and grow the business.

Musk clearly does all of that. Still, for there to be value to be extracted, the workers had to create it.

Hmm, it is murkier: Musk can create 'virtual' value by hype and stock inflation and then extract that value by selling his stock (essentially extracting from investors/stock holders).

reply
Which part of it isn't true?
reply
[dead]
reply
Very debatable.
reply
Musk doesn't even need a replacement.
reply
Oh hell no. You could probably go and do a Luigi on most F500 CEOs and nothing too bad would happen (other than the stonk markets taking a nosedive out of panic).

But try to replace the actually vital people? Oh boy. SpaceX for example, if something were to happen to Musk the engineers would probably be quite happy of being rid of the constant noise. But if something were to happen to Gwynne Shotwell who is the one running SpaceX in practice? Whoops. No bueno.

reply
and that's why we opened up to China and created the WTO.

first we extract gdp then we extract jobs then we extract technology

we're getting a good hard look at what 'deregulation' looks like currently.

reply
You’re about 35 years after the collapse of communism so please bone up on your economic theories
reply
Do you want to argue against the USSA?
reply
Some context on the $50B pay package is in order!

The original package was approved in 2018. Note the $50B was if Tesla hit certain valuations, which at the time nobody believed.

A shareholder lawsuit and left wing judge decided to invalidate it in 2024, after Tesla hit those valuations.

So shareholders voted again to give Elon the pay package, and the judge rejected it.

Then the Delaware Supreme Court overruled and Elon got his $50B.

I’d say the situation is more like getting equity at a startup that is worth nothing, then it turns into billions but you lose it and the board gives it back.

reply
“Left wing judge” is a good tell to not take a poster seriously.
reply
Oh ok, that makes all the context he provided irrelevant then.
reply
It taints the entire comment and makes all of it even more untrustworthy than it already is without sources.
reply
Then fact check it. He’s just stating facts
reply
He's clearly biased, so they're not facts. They're interpretations on what he remembers.
reply
Calm down Nelson. Nothing wrong with a few personal judgements mixed in with facts.
reply
Pesky left wing judges stopping my friend Elon from getting 50 billion dollars!
reply
[dead]
reply
Proportionally, it costs close to nothing to make new shares for Elon's pay package. Since Tesla doesn't have any treasury stock, it also won't have the indirect cost of dilution bringing down the balance sheet.

Rejecting the pay package therefore wouldn't mean "saving" X amount of funds.

reply
Well, no, because there’s opportunity cost involved here. $50 Bn of Tesla stock is roughly $50 Bn of cash. You could have paid it out to employees. Or paid it out to other execs. Or anyone.
reply
Your argument relies on a red herring fallacy. Whether or not it could have been used to pay out employees has nothing to do with the fact it wouldn't be "saving" money with respect to the company balance sheet. The money is being paid out through the dilution of existing shareholders.

A $10m dollar saving would directly impact the company balance sheet.

reply
but Elon is not using that money to buy a yacht. he will put that money back into future technologies. Elon is really different from other billionaires.
reply
Well if it weren't for her hard work Musk may have only made $49.99b.
reply
> .. "wait, why the hell are we trying to save $10m when we could save 50 times as much and not even be at 1% of his pay package?" I have no answer to that

It's funny how the smartest technical people keep falling for this "Management 101" trick. The reality distortion field is strong here

reply
>Then the board voted a $50b pay package for Elon Musk and she's like... "wait, why the hell are we trying to save $10m when we could save 50 times as much and not even be at 1% of his pay package?" I have no answer to that.

The answer is the very next paragraph of your comment!

>Also to your point, the value of someone's work isn't always tangible or directly correlated to the work they do day to day.

Elon is negative value and yet gets paid a stupid amount. Your friend is saving the business millions and doesn't see a dime of that.

Welcome to late-stage capitalism.

reply
This is all purely subjective.

The friend can easily quit and find a better job paying more, why don't they? Likewise, Elon could step down for whatever reason and we'd see what happens to the stock price, maybe it goes down 50b, maybe up, who knows.

I do know that Elon leaving will have a much larger impact (one way or another) than 1 process engineer.

reply
> The friend can easily quit and find a better job paying more

How can you assume that to be true? It depends where they worked and if there are similar open jobs nearby. Are those skills specific to Tesla production line or transferable? If they need to move to find a new job, do they have kids that also need to be moved? There are so many factors involved.

Also who says 1 process engineer? We're talking about a $50B pay package to a guy who already has nearly infinite money - that's enough money for hundreds of employees.

reply
Let’s say that by “hundreds” you’re assuming 500 employees. If you split $50B evenly between 500 employees each employee would walk away with a pay package of $100M. You could afford to pay 100,000 employees a pay package of $500K for one Elon’s salary.
reply
It’s purely objective. Elon is the most overpaid person on earth. Of course his leaving would be more impactful, because his pay is grossly out of proportion with his impact.

It’s an open secret his companies have to manage him so that they can get the actual work done while he is distracted.

reply
[dead]
reply
New word: capitulism

A capitalist society's inevitable capitulation to the lure of capital over all else. The moment that the final nail is hammered into the coffin of what used to be known as the idea of the 'free market'.

reply
Ok, what is your point? Your friend makes more than other people that work there are making. Should everyone be paid the same, who gets to decide what multiple?

None of this objective or fair.

reply
Um, the point is why even care whatsoever about cost cutting to potentially make the product worse, when you could just cut CEO pay? The CEO pay is at a point where it doesn’t even change their life meaningfully in any way.

Yeah it’s not objective or fair, that’s what we’re pointing out. That makes it objectively bad, inefficient, and dare I say fucking stupid

reply
He's paid in newly created shares which have literally zero cost for the company outside of reducing the value of shares, but since their own holdings are negligible it's still a cost of approximately $0.
reply
You can spend money only once? As simple as that.

For a start, the opportunity cost of that sum is non zero

reply
They're not spending money. They are giving him newly issued shares. In this exact scenario it's even a bit more nuanced because his package was in the form of options. So he 'bought' the options meaning Tesla gave him a bunch of newly created stock and then kept a chunk for themselves as well as the cost of the options.

And all of this was also contingent on him dramatically increasing the value of the company. If he failed to do that, he would have gotten $0. It'd be akin to in this scenario where somebody's friend was working on a $10 million saving if her entire team received a salary of $0, and contingent upon the completion of the project, they'd each have received a fraction of the savings generated by it. If they failed, or it somehow did not achieve the desired savings, they'd receive $0.

And furthermore payment would also be in stock meaning that their compensation would be subject to the success of the company, and also would be worth less in "reality" than it was on paper since selling would reduce the price of said stock - probably negligibly for a relatively small amount, but it's still a nuance that's important. If Musk tried to convert his trillion (or whatever) to cash, it'd end up being worth much less than its nominal value.

reply
Bingo, these people don't understand.

It's all CEO bad tax the rich BS. I wish I got paid more sure, but I'm not pretend that I'm more valuable to the company I work at than the CEO.

If they made me CEO and I implemented a pay increase package and decreased my own, I'm pretty sure the stock would tank by more than the amount of the pay increase for everyone else.

reply
> I wish I got paid more sure, but I'm not pretend that I'm more valuable to the company I work at than the CEO.

I genuinely want to understand this position: don't you feel a little gross denigrating yourself like this? To purposefully undervalue yourself compared to another person?

reply
> to the company

> another person

Do you see how these aren’t the same thing?

reply
Both the company and society use the same scalar to measure the value of a person and indicate their worth. There is no difference between "value to society" and "value to a company" under this system.
reply
Your own worth is up to you to decide, but what you provide to society, or to a company is determine by your actions and by your role. And since I feel like this is all a proxy for some sort of unspoken idealism of non-capitalism I'd emphasize that this is all just as true even in a 'true' communist system. Imagine you have this commune of people, completely equal, and two people get into a critical dispute such that both insist they'll only stay if the other guy is kicked out.

One person is a highly skilled doctor - the only one in this particular commune in fact; the other is a janitor. It's not hard to guess who's getting kicked out. And this reality of some being 'more equal' than others would influence every single interaction in society. Even if everybody there genuinely believed everybody is equal, the reality is that some people would be worth much more to that society. So the equality is nothing but a fantasy.

I also find this whole concept trite. My value, as a human, is to my family. I couldn't care less what any company thinks of me so long as I am providing enough to support my family. And while I attach greater value to society as a whole, even that is again secondary to family. I think this obsession on extrinsic measures of value is probably a result of the decline of fertility and thus the decline of family.

reply
> My value, as a human, is to my family.

Heh, you happened to have stumbled upon exactly what I wrote about last month, the overextension of the term "value": https://blog.calebjay.com/posts/meaningless-value/

To save you the click, people often conflate moral worth, personal attachment, instrumental value, and allocation priority, when those are all very different things. I admit that above I was playing around with the idea a bit, though I do find it a little, idk, self diminishing to purposefully place oneself under their boss even in instrumental value. Maybe because I'm co-op-brained now and have seen for myself how effective a worker ownership structure works.

> Imagine you have this commune of people, completely equal, and two people get into a critical dispute such that both insist they'll only stay if the other guy is kicked out.

I've seen this exact situation, actually, and the solution wasn't to keep the "doctor," but for the community to assert that both need to find a resolution because neither was getting kicked out without commiting some kind of harm to the group as a whole. That is to say, instrumental value doesn't get someone greater allocation priority (or authority). I understand that under capitalism, it's supposed to, but we risk getting into an unproductive conversation about who actually has more instrumental value to a corporation if we explore that.

reply
Some people being objectively more valuable to others and society is just reality. It's measurable. Shaming someone for not partaking in some idealistic fantasy only suitable for a preschool classroom or resentful subreddit is the bizarre position to take.
reply
Privately-held companies who perform stabilizing actions like this don’t have an outside sentiment or stock price to sweat.
reply
> but I'm not pretend that I'm more valuable to the company I work at than the CEO.

I mean even if that's true and you believe that, are you like 250000x less valuable than your CEO ?

reply
[dead]
reply