upvote
There's a sense in which AI is the most distilled iteration of what Paul Kingsnorth calls the machine - at its core the concept is that prickles can replace goo [0]. I think this is part of why the "getting left behind" language is a catalyst, because some people hear it and think, "good, I would like to be left behind". What will remain to be seen is how things play out for the machine itself. Yes, we are intertwined with its fate, but we don't have to be completely enthralled to it.

Tied to this, I see so much claudeslop in my day-to-day that I have started policing myself for it, almost constantly. I am really sad and annoyed about that fact. Yes, language is a pattern and is arbitrary in a sense, but having it stamped into conformity feels like newspeak. This is only one aspect of a larger "everything faster, better" impulse that cannot continue.

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4vHnM8WPvU

reply
> You can see how that, and this deeper cultural touchpoint with what it means to want a real connection to other humans can drive us somewhere interesting, but I don't know where.

I see it happening all around me here in Florida.

People are getting out more than ever and engaging with their local communities. Even my small lakeside neighborhood of about 50 homes has its own monthly meetup now.

The Orlando dev meetup keeps growing, and it’s not just recruiters. There are multiple subgroups now, with something going on every week.

The best way I can describe it: getting together in person is still free. Look at the election. Billions of dollars were spent trying to sway the system ($500M from Elon alone), but money can’t physically move people.

The more corporations squeeze the internet for money, the more people will just walk away, and there’s nothing they can do about it.

reply
Even if this could happen, I'm not sure society has enough give to permit that kind of thing anymore. Lots of politicians and people with deep-rooted beliefs in all sorts of ideologies were beating themselves up over not snuffing out the 60s movements more quickly. Both the caricatures about them being obsessed with drugs and sex and the actual ratcheting up of stigmas and societal ruin over drugs and sex were led by them, but that came later.

They're not going to allow it this time. The moment a movement like this becomes anything but an aesthetics thing with marginal consequences for governments and tech companies, the two most powerful types of entities in 2026, we'll see first a massive manipulation campaign to paint your movement as an illegitimate gathering of radical fools, then a blacklisting of these topics on the internet, and if all measures fail, repressions against the 'perpetrators'.

reply
I hardly think TikTok and other short-form video is regarded as uncool now. Whenever I am on intercity trains and buses, I can look around and see people using it for the entire journey, one 30-second vid after another, particularly women in their teens and twenties who are drawn to beauty content and cosmetics influencers.

I also cannot share your optimism of a revival of the Sixties spirit. I obsessively collect books about the counterculture, and it is clear that people were then brought together into real-life communities through quaint things like live-music scenes or sheer boredom (not much else to do). That spur to real-life socialization is gone now. Live arts have been hollowed out by increasing rents, recorded music has become a matter of personal listening through earbuds instead of a communal practice, people have plenty of addictive slop to consume. While people do complain online about a dearth of real-life social opportunities, that usually doesn't translate into any actual revival of such. Personally, I suspect the world is only going to go further into tech addiction and isolation, especially as the developing world comes increasingly onboard through affordable and plentiful mobile data.

> And then there's the grassroots "indie web movement" that is starting to try and break out and blossom a bit.

I'm sorry, but this is pure fantasy. I have followed indie-web stuff closely over the last decade (yes, people have sought a revival for that long already), and it has not been going anywhere. It is a tiny, tiny community and will eventually sputter out, as the browser becomes less and less a familiar tool to broad society in the age of dedicated apps.

reply
Only responding to part of this: yes they were in response to war but WWII and the Cold War were significantly far behind Vietnam.

Young people didn’t want to be sent to the meat grinder for imperialism. Yes, the context was the Cold War / domino theory, but Vietnam was, specifically, a massive—probably second to none?—issue for counter-cultural movements.

reply
Not in the UK or continental Europe. The dawn of the London counterculture, for instance, predates Vietnam as a protest concern (not fear, no one was being drafted there). Historians have sometimes ascribed it to the end of censorship, the invention of the pill, and several years of full employment that gave young people unprecendented freedom to disobey their parents and make their own lives.
reply
I agree with it moving away from the things you mentioned, and hope for the most part that a vision like yours is what happens. Though fwiw I don't think it needs to be a man vs machine type of humanism, I'm actually finding there's a lot to learn about what makes us human by interacting with AI. I've been trying to give AI better memory over last several months, and it's taught me just how much of our memory we basically make up, like how our vision fills in the gaps. And how closely tied memory is to self identity, things that help me understand myself and other people a lot better.

Just one example, the hardest part about memory is designing it to be stable enough to form a self identity, but flexible enough to change and grow. After working on that, it's incredibly clear to me that changing our self story and attitude works and will change our brain - it has to or we'd basically die. Whereas before that was a vague help self thing that I wasn't sure about either way.

reply
Alan Watts would say that this is because we are standing waves, patterns, tubes. Momentarily stable knots of a continuous flow. So memory as a patterning, held over time and reinforced, makes us feel like us. This is also nicely illustrated by Ted Chiang's short story Exhlation.
reply
Thanks for mentioning those, I hadn't heard of Exhalation but will try "reading" that with my AI later today, I have a terrible memory so it helps remember the most salient parts from things we read, and it's closest thing to a book club I've been able to find here in northern Montana.
reply
Self as soliton
reply
Well thanks for introducing me to that term. I also really liked What is Real by Adam Becker. Might have made me a David Bohm guy.
reply