upvote
>There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though.

Part of the reason why so many governments have banned single room occupancy housing (the other part is a selfish desire to not allow “those types” to live nearby).

reply
What are "those types"???
reply
People who can only afford SROs.
reply
Especially as the ratio of elderly to young working age people continues to increase.
reply
I don't find the thought revolting, but I do find it concerning

A society that is willing to leave the care of people in the "hands" of machines seems so uncaring to the point of not caring for people at all. I'm fully expecting that the sort of society that will leave human care up to automation would just as easily run people through furnaces instead. After all, no one cares enough to look after them so why keep them around at all?

> when the idealized version isn’t attainable pragmatic people start accepting the second-best solution. There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though

If you wanna talk about unpragmatic versus pragmatic, it's clear what the actual pragmatic choice is, isn't it?

reply
The actual pragmatic choice is to do what humans have done for tens or hundreds of thousands of years, and it's that children take care of their parents in old age, rather than insist on some underclass of strangers do it. Whether that stranger is human or machine is kind of irrelevant.
reply
Society has evolved (people don't have enough kids) and people'a life choices too (kids don't want taking care of their parents to be a main purpose in life and parents don't want their kids to want that).

Btw, those who could afford it have always outsourced this. The blessings of the upper class over millenia.

reply
It's unfortunate that it's fashionable these days to not have children and people just assume that someone else's children will look after them when they're old. Now who's looking after those people's parents?! "Looking after" is quite broad - all the way from changing adult diapers to road maintenance.
reply
I don't want my kids changing my adult diapers if I have any choice in the matter. Better a robot or another human I pay.
reply
> The actual pragmatic choice is to do what humans have done for tens or hundreds of thousands of years, and it's that children take care of their parents in old age

This is true in some cultures

In other cultures it was expected that the elderly, infirm, sickly, or crippled would go walk into the woods so they were no longer a burden for the younger generations. Many cultures used to kill children that were born "wrong" too.

I'm just saying it's entirely possible the value of human life is currently going down, not up. I find that very troubling

reply
Maybe we are not taking about the same kind of care: physical vs psychological.

I don't think that many people will have a problem with a robot cleaning wounds, changing bandages, preparing meals because you can't, etc... if it does a good job. Care here is just making sure your wound heals properly. A nurse can also provide psychological care in a way machines can't, but does it have to go together with treating a wound? Some people don't need psychological care, they just need a new bandage, others have a body that needs no intervention but may need psychological care.

reply
I think a lot of people will have big problems with that. What happens when someone with dementia has a wound that needs to be cleaned but they don't have the faculties to consent. Does the robot hold them down and violate their autonomy, or does it phone home and wait for intervention while the person hurts themselves (intentionally or not)?
reply
That's kind of my point. Dementia is a mental disease and that is likely to require human care. A wound only needs a bandage change, a technical operation that is hard for robots. A nurse can do both, but it doesn't mean every patient needs both. Most patients in need of a bandage change have the ability to consent and don't need human care if a robotic bandage changer can do the job well enough. For those who don't, bring the nurse, and because nurses won't have to deal with patients who can use the robot, they can spend more time caring for those who can't.
reply
I feel it is extreme to jump from "people have more things to do than being 24/7 caretakers for multiple adults" (a natural consequence of an aging and shrinking population) to claiming that this means that they would rather put people in furnaces instead.

There's such a massive gap of things in between that are far more sane and likely where things would end up if such robotics actually pan out.

reply
there's a huge difference between caring about people (good) and caring for people (a necessary task but there is nothing virtuous in the task itself, and a lot of it is tedious and unpleasant work that if it could be automated without loss of patient comfort should be)
reply
Perhaps separate the emotional care like having a chat from the physical care like putting them on the toilet and changing their clothes. I think plenty of old people will be happy with a gentle robot doing the physical stuff if they can still hang out with their family.
reply