upvote
Reminds me a bit of that line about how wine experts can’t tell the difference between expensive and cheap wines.

Except when you look into who counts as a wine expert, it ends up being a bunch of college students and people that took a weekend course.

reply
It's nothing like that at all - that's maybe the worst analogy.

Financial accounting is a very real thing, it's complicated, there are standards, vagaries, companies do odd things sometimes out of laziness, malice, or necessity.

It's a very real discipline.

reply
That's what they're saying. "Wine experts can't tell" is a myth, because wine expert-dom is actually a very real discipline, and if you narrowed the field down to actual wine experts, they can tell.
reply
Brief aside:

>"Wine experts can't tell" is a myth

It's really not a myth. This has been tested several times (at least once a year) in several different ways. Even the most expert of experts don't really have a clue.

[1]https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/23/wine-ta...

reply
That's nonsense. None of these studies even mention the level of official Sommelier training (hint, people who are not level 4 are not experts). One of the studies even claims that people (note, not experts) can't tell the difference between red and white. Which is ridiculous, white wine is made without the skins that contain the tannins. Anyone who is fooled by dye is absolutely not a wine expert.
reply
so it proved anyone that's not specifically trained for the job of picking the difference (and that difference also doesn't mean the expensive is more enjoyable) won't get it?
reply
That’s a much higher standard and experience than kpmg usually utilizes for their audit practice. Which I think supports the opposing argument being made here before the wine expert specific argument took over.
reply
I worked alongside a master vinter helping a small local winery set up shop for about a year. He loved sharing his knowledge, and it was 0% pretentious- the man was simply an expert in a highly complicated craft. I left my time there with a great deal of respect for the profession!
reply
Sommelier != vinter
reply
The problem is you will also find people like this in homeopathy. But cargo cult science is still not real science, no matter how much work these people put in their job. In the absence of widely agreed upon education and examination, all this effort is worthless once you leave these bubbles of people who believe you without evidence.
reply
It is sufficient to find 1 wine expert who can identify wines with a reasonable correctness rate in a blind test to claim that it is possible to do so. The fact that many claim to be experts but are not doesn’t change that.

Does such an expert exist? (I have no idea.)

reply
There are no 'pretend accountants'.

They literally have accreditation + levels, professional bodies, very well defined standards, 'apprenticeships', and usually institutional professionalism aka firms with practice, client bases, standards, internal know-how.

It's totally the opposite of 'wine tasting'.

reply
Sure. But companies like KPMG won't waste their top accountants on small fry customers. They might have one seasoned guy among the team of novices they use to reel you in initially but they'll quickly pull him out once you've signed unless you're worth the trouble.

I'm not saying they're wrong not to want to waste their good folks on boring low-stakes/low-revenue clients but it does feel a bit dishonest that they try to get those signed in the first place when they don't really care about them in the first place.

This might of course be regionally different - it's a worldwide operation so conduct can vary of course.

reply
is the chatbot a pretend accountant?
reply
Most of the studies on wine tastings don't involve experts, just enthusiasts who think they're experts. However there is actually a test for this (for master sommeliers aka the only true wine experts).

Part of the test is a blind taste test. Most people fail because it because you need to be able identify not just the type of wine but it's vintage and even year.

reply
Isn't that sort of the case for everything? 80% of practitioners of any given work or hobby will have only 20% of the "collective total skill", according to some hand-wavy definition of that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle

Perhaps I'm explaining it badly, but my belief is that most people doing any given thing are quite bad at it, and a small minority of skilled individuals raise the average (mean).

Also a footnote regarding wine tasting in particular, even judges in top wine competitions aren't statistically much better than randomness, see for example: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/23/wine-ta...

> a bunch of college students and people that took a weekend course

Do you by this include people who graduated with a two-year degree in the study of winemaking? Perhaps it's not exactly being an "expert", but it's quite far from a weekend course, I'd say. A better term might be "wine professional". In any case, such a sample were unable to tell red wine apart from white wine with red dye in it...

> The wine comparison test was carried out by 54 undergraduates from the Faculty of Oenology of the University of Bordeaux

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00939...

reply
I dont even like wine but even I can tell the difference between a white wine and a red wine by texture alone. Anyone who can't do that basic feat doesn't qualify as a wine enthusiast let alone an "expert".
reply
Actual experts are usually busy making their own wine and don't have time for BS.
reply
The entire big 4 in my experience do not care about service quality. They have a wide portfolio, do not need to hunt for jobs. They do the minimum, make mistakes yet they get clients.
reply
You're not paying for service. Any idiot can look over your numbers and give you the results. You're paying for protection. When some predatory party comes around thinking you're gonna be their payday you need to be able to have your lawyer be able to say to the POS across the table "our shit is clean this paper that proves it was performed by <name of company with a legal department bigger than some nation's armies> so take it up with them".
reply
The one thing the big 4 and AI have in common is they're both essentially resource extraction operations.
reply
AI doesnt tire.

You could state this much more strongly even. It's the entire industry, not just KMPG.

reply
KMPG associates work for partners maxxing for comp and profitability. AI works tirelessly for whomever pays for it, and can be widely distributed. The question is: who owns the gains or surplus from the productivity realized in this context and use case.
reply
AI works for whomever created it. And it's in their best interest to guarantee that you use the maximum amount of tokens possible
reply
> AI works tirelessly for whomever pays for it, and can be widely distributed. The question is: who owns the gains or surplus from the productivity realized in this context and use case.

The point of AI is to compete with the human workforce by replacing labor contracts and working hours for human workers with service contracts and usage quotas for AI. If a company can reduce its human workforce capacity use by 20% through the use of AI, it can lay off up to 20% of its workforce and spend up to 100% of the savings on AI - even spending only 50% of it on AI would be a major win for AI companies once they operate at profitable margins.

I'm saying that as someone who uses AI every day and has a Claude Ultra subscription. The point of AI is to move the money paid in wages to money paid to the AI companies (or if the AI is being developed and operated in-house, keep it inside the company and thus generate more profit to be extracted by shareholders/investors).

reply
It does tire, that’s context rot. It’s just that AI can rest and reawaken fresh as fast as you can write “compacting…”
reply
Better yet, your initial agent can spawn dozens or hundreds of fresh minions that each look in excruciating detail at one small area, then other agents that analyze their reports and look for potential issues that span their domains.

Much as with real people, the context window is addressed through collaboration, and it turns out agents are extremely good at that too.

reply
Most models start to noticeably degrade around the 100k token neighborhood, which is still hundreds of pages of text that can be attended to more or less densely. Somehow it's just normalized to cram a small novelette into everything as an excruciatingly verbose system prompt.
reply
for comparison, this whole comment page is roughly 10k tokens.

how well would a human fare, trying to recall the details from ten of these?

reply
AI doesn't understand that "he who pays the piper gets to call the tune."
reply
It's a single prompt away though unless strong safeguards are put in place, and even then...
reply
KPMG churns low salary new grads. You typically work there until experienced enough to get out.
reply
I interviewed at Deloitte and PwC and their salaries weren't great either, probably just the norm in the consulting industry.
reply
Absolutely the norm. Get smart recent grads, pay them peanuts, they'll do it because the name looks great on their CV. Then they'll leave and you get the next batch in. You just need a few older, more experienced folks overseeing them so they don't make too many obvious mistakes.

The entire consulting industry works on this.

reply
KPMG is also considered the worst of the Big 4
reply
None are good though, B4 are decidedly tier 3 in the management consulting world for instance.
reply
This is intentional by design.

Average consultants are more profitable than skilled ones.

Plus companies get to overpay for the education of juniors.

After all, they have all those fresh ideas the big companies are looking for.

Oops, did I say consultant instead of accountant? AI definitely will run most of an accounting department on its own.

reply
[dead]
reply