upvote
He is right. It’s just that selling bare metal doesn’t scale and we must sell VMs instead, so we can't understand his point.

Since he made that comment there has been numerous virtualization vulnerabilities in KVM, Xen, HyperV, and all other hypervisors as well as all their device virtualization helpers/ecosystem. I fail to see how Theo's statement is anything but 100% right. It's just that we can't live with it because we must sell VMs.

There is a reason you graduate to bare metal, then you graduate to air gapped.

reply
Bare metal has nothing to do with his point. He's comparing cotenant shared kernel to cotenant virtual kernel, and he's wrong: virtualization drastically reduces the attack surface.
reply
Is he? I didn't follow the entire thread, but it doesn't seem to discuss shared kernel, just whether the security of x86 virtualization is real or if it's just a convenient way to run multiple kernels on the same x86 host. If you don't trust x86 virtualization as a security boundary, then your down to bare metal and hoping that your networking cards and switches don't have some vulnerability too.

Virtualization does reduce the attack surface, but it's still there. This is a thread for a hole in it.

reply
I wouldn't say wildly wrong. I would say virtualization is a lot better than nothing, but that there's a pile of hacks with a pile of vulnerabilities (Spectre/Meltdown come to mind) is undeniable. It's just there's no need to tell people they are stupid or worse for using it.
reply
Microarchitectural attacks hit cotenant shared-kernel workloads harder than they hit virtual machines.
reply
Well he's not really. It's just useful and shit!
reply