upvote
I really strongly disagree with this. Let's say you have all the data. You release it. How many people are going to go audit it? Not many. So instead of you, a journalist who actually has a professional interest in this and a reputation to build, you're handing analysis off to clout chasers. Suddenly whoever can find the most explosive viral take will win. Not the most accurate take. The most viral. And the most viral is often something just wrong enough to engage those who want to believe it whilst also engaging those who know enough to refute it - that's where you hit the sweet spot of engagement. Sure someone could go back to the original published data and debunk it - well done, you're driving engagement and uninformed people aren't going to see you debunking it, they're going to 90% see the original false claim, and 10% see a debate they know nothing about which is 50:50 on what they end up believing.

Far more effective is for you to listen to different journalists opinions and reporting over time and answer two questions: "Is this person acting with integrity?" and "What are their biases that I need to factor into my analysis". It is much more important to be listening to journalists who have clear ethical standards - even if you disagree with them.

reply
This is a well formed and convincing justification for not initially releasing the raw data.

I don't agree with it but it's not crazy ...

However there is no good justification for not releasing the raw data eventually, which it appears will not occur.

reply
The line between "building reputation" and "chasing clout" is very blurry.
reply
The Snowden leaks didn't result in raw data being dumped for the same reason that these internal files won't be. The cowboy method of truly unfiltered access is dangerous and irresponsible. Wikileaks learned this lesson in a very public manner and even Wikileaks didn't escape issues of injecting personal narratives into their reporting that was dubbed objective. Surely we don't need to explain the difference between white hat and black hat actors to HN, right?

Raw data is only a piece too. Journalism is more than rewording a stolen document. It's following leads, establishing sources, and connecting both public and private data points into a narrative that otherwise wouldn't be discoverable.

I find your gripe attributes a blanket presumption of incompetence and malice on journalists. It reads as condescending.

The reason why this story is distributed across so many publications is to quell concerns of deception by omission or similar. Perhaps all the publications fell for the same trick or are in on the same lie, but this is as close to "compile from source" as you can get with reporting on sensitive, stolen, and secret information.

reply
> I find your gripe attributes a blanket presumption of incompetence and malice on journalists. It reads as condescending.

I think, things like this forms somewhat distrusting nature of the news agencies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Lincoln_Memorial_confront...

Shorter video showed maga hat wearer was complete asshole, while in longer version one might argue that the drummer was the one testing the boundaries and patience.

Was it reported by a professional serious journalist with good reputation? I don’t know, but it definitely was covered by serious news outlets.

reply
News outlets, even the most reputable ones, have been found to withhold stories to curry favor with those in power. For example, in September 2004, CBS News postponed a completed 60 Minutes investigation questioning the Bush administration's pre-war WMD intelligence (including forged Niger uranium documents).

And before the 2003 Iraq war, the NYT (the "gold standard" of journalism) published numerous front-page stories, many co-authored by Judith Miller, claiming Saddam Hussein possessed active weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs, relying heavily on administration officials and Iraqi defectors such as Ahmad Chalabi.

And before the November 2004 U.S. presidential election, New York Times reporters James Risen and Eric Lichtblau uncovered the Bush administration's secret National Security Agency (NSA) warrantless domestic surveillance program. Executive Editor Bill Keller and Washington Bureau Chief Philip Taubman decided not to publish the investigation prior to the 2004 election following meetings with White House and intelligence officials who argued publication would compromise national security. The Time held the story for over a year, finally publishing it in December 2005.

reply
Because there’s probably a lot of data in there where nothing wrong happened and the people in the data have the right to not have their data published.

It’s not like it’s a tiny cabal, but a huge amount of media companies. If you cannot trust a broad spectrum of journalists then we have a much larger problem.

reply
And we have this much bigger problem. It's called gatekeeping.
reply
So instead of journalists “gatekeeping” you’d prefer “influencers” and other professional provocateurs? Because, let’s be honest, Joe Public isn’t going to be trawling through the raw data. Instead they’ll be fed the hottest takes from their preferred bias-bubble distributor.
reply
And so what? Who are journalists to say that they should be entitled to analyze this data and present it to the public and not let anyone they don't approve of to do it?

If Joe Public prefers getting hot takes from influencers, then let them? The public gets what they deserve.

reply
You talk as if you’re not one of the public. Perhaps you’re a HN alumni who’s done so well you can afford to think of yourself as separate from the hoi polloi and unaffected by the capricious nature of populism. I however am definitely one of the public and if it’s all the same to you I don’t believe I “deserve” to live in a worse world. I’d rather we try for a better one thanks.
reply
[flagged]
reply
If we can trust a broad spectrum of journalists why have democracy at all?
reply
reply
Agree - release it all.
reply
Bias in journalism today? It's always been there and always will be (of course varying in extent and direction).
reply
reply
Well, in my defense, I wasn't around when Hearst was around, so ... ;-D
reply
Well considering that you don't seem to have a problem with it, why don't you start? Just release all your banking history, credit card details, mortgages etc. publically for us to sift through?
reply
I would, but I don't have a Deutsche Bank account, so there's nothing to release, sorry!
reply
it's way more banal than this.

the simple fact is that the data that leaked re: Deutsche Bank, most of it is meaningless IT-related noise. the second most parsimonious explanation is that it would reveal the origin of the leak (almost certainly an IT worker who misused credentials) by the nature of what it doesn't see.

this was the case with Disney's leaked Slack channels. meaningless IT noise, clear who it came from, little newsworthy value.

it's interesting to me that ProPublica is not on their list. i can see from their stories why.

reply
[flagged]
reply
[dead]
reply