upvote
Similar approach as with casinos, ethanol, asbestos, tobacco, prostitution, drugs, slavery, labour law abuse, and others. They are not banned, but regulated, because they are proven to have negative impact, often visible only in long run. So there is a middle ground between doing nothing and banning everything. The problem is that politicians are 10+ years behind, and super reactive on problems. Lobbying/corruption also must take its toil. We went through this for example during boom of ad tracking, and the problem was addressed despite a lot of squealing from big techs and the ad industry.
reply
How are you going to regulate intelligence?

When have you gone "too far" with statistics?

Its inherently a different, geopolitical problem than a private health one

reply
We regulate guns, so we can regulate intelligence, because it can be as deadly as gunpowder.

Practically it means people can go to jail if they don't comply with regulations.

reply
You're not answering the questions, how do you define what is too much with intelligence and statistics?

How do you ensure that everyone follows this measure of "too much"? Mass surveillance?

Tobacco, guns and nuclear weapons are not used by the average person to make decisions on which route to take to work

reply
We regulate guns by ensuring that the governments have the biggest guns. Do you want this to happen to intelligence?
reply
Should we unban the development of nuclear weapons then? Somehow I don't think that humanity's strength was adaptation in that regard. We banned a dangerous technology and were better off for it.
reply
1960: ~20,000 nuclear warheads around the world

1967~1970: The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons was signed into force

1980: ~54,000 nuclear warheads around the world

That was how we "banned" nuclear weapons. When you hear "ban A" you should automatically translate it to "ensure that only a few most powerful entities can have A" in your head.

reply
We didn't ban nuclear weapons, we capitalized on them being extremely difficult to build.

AI doesn't afford us that same luxury of nuclear weapon deterrence.

Bans do don't shit to stop interest parties.

reply
I don't think nuclear weapons were banned out of moral enlightenment... They just have 0 ROI for the private sector, there is no market for them. And they are bulky, difficult to make, and require a bunch of stuff like centrifuges, it's a much simpler task to agree upon. If you instantly got 2bn$ for every detonated nuke, I think the world would look different.

It's different with code and LLMs because there is actually a market for this. It's more like you are trying to ban excel spreadsheets or something. They are already out, a shitload of people use them, and you get outcompeted by countries/companies that don't ban them.

reply