upvote
I took a quick look at The Anarchist's Tool Chest and noticed in Chapter 20 a short vignette about an expert woodworker named Troy that seemed... oddly familiar.

According to the author, Troy could do the work of three people. That would make him a 3x woodworker, I guess. And he was facing automation in the woodworking industry.

"But Troy decided to compete with the machines on their own turf. He tried to become a one-man factory. He succeeded in that. But the most efficient one-man factory cannot compete with a factory driven by a hundred men.

So no matter what Troy did, the prices for work (good or otherwise) declined. Ikea’s well-designed kitchens and Value City’s cheap junk made it impossible to survive and live well.

So Troy struggled with his business. And that’s nuts. He should have had more business than he could handle. But like many professional cabinetmakers I know, it became harder and harder for him to make ends meet every year. His cabinetmaking business is closed, and the last time we talked, Troy was working for his wife’s successful tax business.

Who is to blame for this? We are.

We have become a culture that is obsessed with price more than any other attribute of the things we buy. It doesn’t matter if the item is ugly, poorly made or constructed of materials that cannot be recycled. All that matters is if the price is low enough.

Because the price of our household objects has hit rock bottom, if an item breaks or starts to look dated, we can throw it away and buy some- thing else. For the first time in human history, manufactured furniture is shockingly inexpensive.

So it’s no wonder that artisans are exiting the craft. It’s difficult to compete against furniture that costs less than what you pay for your raw materials.

Lesson: People cannot imitate machines and defeat them."

reply
The lesson is that most people aren't discerning consumers in multiple fields.

Appreciating good design, quality craftsmanship, having taste in food.. having these "elevated" tastes in multiple areas is very rare for humans. Take a look at a musician - they can tell you precisely what makes a quality violin, but they might not care that they eat microwave frozen dinners. You compound that across the population and the artisans will always lose out to the mass-produced slop because it's impossible to naturally get a critical mass of people to care about that quality curve. You have to sell them on it.

Troy struggled because he failed at marketing, not production.

reply
Or even single fields. I've purchased my parents the "nicer" version of things and they inevitably end up back on some crappier version. Japanese knives? Nope, still use the ones that barely cut. Ubiquiti wifi system that covered their whole house? Nope, dad unplugged something, got frustrated, and the cable company came over and put them back on the old crappy system. Nice speakers? Nope, they listen to music on their crappy TV speakers.

I think I've learned that most people don't want to put in any effort to learn or appreciate things that may be of nicer quality. Those Japanese knives didn't do any good for them because they didn't spend time learning how to use them properly. In fact one of them used them improperly and ended up needing stitches. So in the end the crappier version is no different than the nicer version, because crappy and nice are about the potential of the item, and most people don't see potential. Does this Ikea dresser hold clothes? Great, who cares that the other one is of nicer wood, the joinery is done by hand, and it'll last multiple generations.

reply
On the other hand, there's an accessibility to products of higher median quality to more people than would have existed even only five generations ago.
reply