upvote
Claude the model has no moat.

Claude the product has a moat.

People build up skills, memories, dashboards, and now documents and wikis in it. It’s getting increasingly sticky in enterprise. They know the model has no moat; now they are using the model to capture corporate workflows that become more difficult to swap out.

reply
It’s pretty easy to tell codex to import and adapt all your Claude skills and memories and vice versa, so I’m not sure how much of a moat all that is until they start making it inaccessible to you.
reply
>I’m not sure how much of a moat all that is

The way I see it is that AI usage is starting to go the way of automobile favoritism. Does it really matter whether someone gets a Ford F-150, a Chevrolet Silverado, or a Dodge Ram? Not really, they're all trucks that can be had in a variety of colors, cab sizes, bed sizes, and engine choices, but you'll find that people can become fanboys of one brand or another for whatever reason, and they generally don't switch unless they experience some colossal failure. I think the same thing is going to happen with AI providers, the favoritism itself is the moat.

reply
I would say its almost like Apple vs Android. Yes, Android could make a phone that could do exactly the same thing. But Apple became "the standard" (at least in America).

Claude is currently doing this -- it is so ubiquitous in corporations that people are building full Claude workflows and harnesses.

Maybe it will be easy to transfer all that to a different LLM, but I think it's also possible that they could end up with a similar Walled Garden as Apple without having a far superior product, per se

reply
Yeah they seem to be chasing a classic integrations and sticky-identity playbook. But it is weird this time because the product itself can trivially recreate or bypass the moat. Phones did not happily and actively unravel their makers’ competitive differentiation when asked to do so by their users.
reply
[flagged]
reply
I think many recognized a while back that their safety and doomerism was (at least partially) a way of trying to create one by baiting governments into regulations they could shape to crystallize their position alongside OpenAI and FAANG.
reply