upvote
I suspect they may want to get away from the size class due to the fact that - at the pace they are launching new models - and the similarity of model sizes between Neon/Carbon, Opus/Fable, Sol/Astra - the best model is going to be the most recently released one, not the biggest one.

I'm not sure it's much better than 4.1 Flash vs 4 Pro -> if 4.1 Flash is better temporarily when Pro is typically significantly better, people are going to be confused.

I'm not really sure how you get around this problem easily.

It's not going to age well when the next Flash-lite model launches, but maybe they will call that `Gemini 4 <Element>-lite` - who knows...

reply
Interesting. You're claiming that the Opus/Sol/Neon class and Fable/Astra/Carbon class models are similar sizes to each other? That would be surprising to me.

I've found that while Opus 5.5 is often pretty nice for practical work, Fable (even 5.0) is still significantly smarter on hard tasks and makes far fewer "dumb mistakes"

reply
A Microsoft Azure page briefly claimed Sol runs with less looped transformer passes; and so you could speculate that Sol and Astra might share weights; but have different “loop” factors.

That would make a lot of sense from an inference optimisation perspective. The same prefill and decode machines can hold one set of weights, and serve both Astra and Sol requests.

At (multi-)terabyte-scale model weights, and when you have to offer not just the latest like Fable 5.2 but still serve 5.1, 5.0, etc; heck I think Opus 4.6 is still around; you really care about overall compute utilisation.

Idle GPUs are wasted GPUs; and even over the fastest interlinks you’re not hotswapping multi terabytes of weights.

With MoEs, there’s probably stuff you can play around with varying the number of active experts; or other clever optimisations.

Maybe Sonnet 5.5 could be just Opus 5.5 with a different router and less active params? Who knows; I’m just theorycrafting now :)

reply
> A Microsoft Azure page briefly claimed Sol runs with less looped transformer passes;

This doesn't really make sense given how the models released.

OpenAI released Astra long before latent-space looping was a thing at the frontier space.

Then they released Sol 6, which was fast, clearly not looped. Then they release Sol 6.1 which was nearly as good as Astra, but way cheaper, and WAY slower -> this would follow it just being a looped version of Sol 6.

It doesn't seem likely that Astra 6.2 is just a looped Astra 6... It's too fast, and they'd go bankrupt if they're charging the same price... It may be a further looped version of Sol than Sol 6.2 - which would explain why it's not as much better as we would've hoped.

It may also explain why their release is not going as well as they hoped. It's hard to predict how your first looped models are going to fare.

If you look at how long it took Google to recover from their failed 3.5 Pro, it would be surprising if GPT recovered from their rumored failed run on Astra in under a month. That would give them reason to release a looped Sol and call it Astra.

reply
Looped transformers have been known for years now. I don't think it's something new.
reply
They are JUST arriving to frontier models.

Even in the open weight Chinese models as small as DeepSeek V4.1 Flash - nothing is looped.

reply
I think they're responding to the claim Astra can't be looped, there's clear and convincing research, as well as public comms, that it is. It's unclear why Astra can't be looped because looping is new, but, 6.1 Sol released a week later can be.
reply
Astra was the first shipping looper. Unconvincing evidence would be reporting x OpenAI's quick reaction to it via a blog post from their chief research (it broke what's considered a safety taboo). Convincing evidence would be research from ex. Neel Nanda on serial reasoning, recent update at https://x.com/EpochAIResearch/status/2122762411287748696?a=J...
reply
I heard rumours that Sol 6.1 was cut down Astra because Sol 6.0 was received badly. But I thought that was the exception (and a result of Open AI's actual Sol-class model being uncompetitive) rather than the rule.
reply
That would line up - on release and for the few following weeks Sol 6.1 felt like Astra but maybe more task oriented, recently it’s been a noticeable downgrade in the level of specification needed to successfully set off.
reply
deleted
reply
Fable & Opus, Astra & Sol, and Carbon are all thought to be >1T param models - AFAIK, most people think Opus & Sol are ~5T param models and Astra, Fable are 10T+.

I think the rumor-mill consensus is that Google's models are significantly smaller while attempting to swing at the same level - but the ratios AFAIK are thought to be around the same - i.e. Neon is somewhere around half as big as Carbon, big enough that a newer checkpoint can make it temporarily a little bit better.

reply
So many figures and ratios pulled from a single ass
reply
There's only a limited amount of hardware for training and serving models at scale, and which form an upper bound for what model size/inference can support.

A GB300 rack has 72x288GB=20TB VRAM. Do the math and 10T parameter models are just about the max size you can easily train and serve (at 1M context) without doing a lot of custom hardware development or limiting your scale.

reply
The Bitter Lesson - Richard Sutton (2019)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19393432

reply
deleted
reply
reply
You violated the only constraint the question contained.
reply
Honestly, the bigger question is, are they at some point start adding numbers (Carbon 2, Neon 1.5, Hydrogen+ ionized), or are they keep giving a new name to every single new model. Argon seems to have been basically "replaced" by Carbon.
reply
I hope they will continue to use numbers. Right now it's "Gemini 4 Hydrogen" in the UI, that seems to be the way it will be used.
reply
Carbon is just Argon with extended thinking.
reply
Subscribing for Gemini 19 Bismuth
reply
Think of it like a riddle: given the order and naming scheme, OP has to imagine what Google thinks when naming the models...
reply
Why does this chart not include the other gemini 4 model, Argon? Also I am sure somebody thought about which element to name which model and it would be very helpful to me if they would explain their reasoning. OpenAI's naming got kind of abstract with 5.6 but I could follow it: Luna(Moon) was smallest, Terra (Earth) was medium, Sol (Sun) was biggest. Astra kind of breaks from that but whatever. But like I would genuinely appreciation someone from google to explain the reasoning behind their element names. Like are Argon and Neon related in some way because they are both noble gases? Is hydrogen the smallest model because it is the lightest element? Carbon has a lower atomic number than neon but is more expensive and presumably bigger... maybe I am overthinking this.
reply
Argon is already deprecated.
reply
Inconsistently it seems. On the $20/mo tier, Argon has been removed from the web interface and app, but is still available in Antigravity (while Carbon is only on the $100/mo tier in both).
reply
Uh yeah, is this the big news of this announcement? They are moving all the good coding models into the Ultra price tier.
reply
Are they? Neon seems great and it’s available on the Pro tier.
reply
I'm going by the model labels in Gemini.
reply
Leave it to Google to create a card that goes from highest to lowest, and not the other way around
reply
I have to assume they're messing with something other than size here - nobody would be this bad at naming different model sizes. Maybe sequence length or post-training strategy or sparseness or something else with the architecture.

(Although why they'd release all ~four is a mystery. I guess they're having a hard time picking the "best" one and so are just putting them all out to let the public decide.)

reply
“Model size class” is a completely meaningless taxonomy.

It doesn’t correlate with intelligence, speed or price furthermore you have no way of telling what the model sizes of “like for like” named models from oai or Anthropic are.

reply
/me pours one out for neural scaling laws
reply
Did you read and somehow fail to understand the chinchilla paper?
reply
Do you believe the amount of available training data has stopped growing?
reply
deleted
reply
I assume atomic weight. Neon seems to be better than Carbon, also faster and cheaper (all judging by the link)
reply
What about Argon though?
reply
Apparently even Google wants to pretend it doesn't exist.
reply
But Argon has a higher atomic weight than both, and sits below Carbon and above Hydrogen. Also, Carbon is rated at better at long-horizon tasks while Neon seems to be smarter at contained work. So they're not strictly better/worse.
reply
Great, consumers now need to first learn chemistry to be able to figure out which model to use!
reply
That's my thought too. If one needs a lookup table to understand the product by name then it's a product issue, not a consumer issue, even if everyone "should" have the first N elements memorized by atomic $property.
reply
melting point/boiling point
reply
Ugh, this sound so overly nerdy, that it could be very true. I do not follow or care about the Google LLM releases just because the naming scheme is so convoluted (and the constant churn of products around the llms). I learned the anthropic naming scheme, it is stable and easy to follow. And this is why Claude is my daily driver. I don't like change, I like stable and predictable progress. Open AI naming scheme is kind of easy to learn (bigger planet = bigger model). But fuck Googles bullshit naming crap, seriously.
reply
meant to be an opus/sol competitor, looks like. not fable/astra
reply
If there is, it isn’t obvious, which makes it terrible.
reply
The developer guide lists

    Gemini 4 Neon (NEW!)
    Gemini 4 Hydrogen (NEW!)
    Gemini 4 Carbon (NEW!)
    Gemini 4 Argon (NEW!
    Gemini 3.8 Live 
    Gemini 3.8 Flash (NEW!)
    Gemini 3.7 Flash
    Gemini 3.6 Flash
    Gemini 3.5 Flash
I've no clue whatsoever how to read anything about the names of them and what they might imply you would use them for though. Within these most of them have LOW MEDIUM HIGH XHIGH, with the default being different for some of them, how anybody is possibly meant to understand this whole matrix of ambiguously named products is beyond me.
reply
Same here. First i thought it would be noble gasses. Then I thought it would be about the atomic weights. I know, I should just ask AI to figure it out for me, but its a bit humiliating.
reply

    Hydrogen 1
    Carbon 6 
    Neon 10
    Argon 18
Maybe this implies that Neon is smaller than Argon in weight size, but it's newer, but it's also only a little bigger than Carbon? Do the Nobel gas models have more safeguards? Is Carbon 6x the size of Hydrogen and a third the size of Argon? When they release Xeon can we make compounds? Feels like some really cheap Da Vinci Code esque thing if we're supposed to get some sort of meaning out of the names.
reply
From their Neon marketing:

> In our early evaluations, it matched or exceeded Gemini 4 Carbon on overall quality at 3x the speed and 60% of the cost. We’re excited to bring these capabilities to Glean customers tackling multi-step work that demands accuracy, detail, and speed.

So possibly smaller than Carbon? Or some other axis that is making it faster and cheaper? No idea.

reply
Same. Running my benchmarks to verify their quality claims. Carbon performed very well on my private suite - spitting distance to Opus 5.5.
reply
It could be worse, they could have named them after different Google chat products.
reply
How do you decide which model is best for telling you which model to use?
reply
It’s just a matter of time before we have

- Gemini (New)

- Gemini

- Gemini (original)

reply
This is Google, it'd be:

- Gemini (Not ready yet)

- Gemini (Deprecated)

reply
They could take a page from Nintendo: New Super Gemini Deluxe!
reply
Inb4 they switch it back to Bard.
reply
Classic Gemini
reply
Hydrogen is the new flash, at least
reply
As far as I can tell it's arbitrary and Google is just choosing element names they think sound good.

When Argon first came out it seemed like they could be going for noble gasses, like Helium (small), Neon (mid), Argon (big).

But then Carbon came out and it seemed like maybe they were going through the alphabet for model generations. Argon, Boron (internal), Carbon.

And now they've come out with Hydrogen and Neon, and there's no logical way to order them. The actual model sizes are Hydrogen (small), Neon (mid), Carbon (big). This doesn't match sorting by atomic number or alphabetically.

reply
They are almost certainly being ambiguous so that people rely on the model descriptors to pick which one to use.

I think there are a ton of people who automatically default to the largest model with the highest thinking for everything. Which historically made sense but not nearly as much anymore.

At this point a model like hydrogen can cover just about everything an average person is doing. You don't need Carbon deploying an agent swarm pushing terabytes of parameters through HBM memory to help you plan your birthday party.

reply
Wouldn't such users immediately run into quota walls?
reply
They do, and then they complain.

Worse, people burning dumb prompts on large models also has the net effect of shrinking quotas for everyone.

reply
(S) Gemini 4 Hydrogen - fastest - $1.50/$7.50

(M) Gemini 4 Neon - second fastest - $3/$15

(L) Gemini 4 Argon - second slowest - $2/$10 (till Nov 30), $4/$20 (> Nov 30)

(XL) Gemini 4 Carbon - slowest - $2/10 (till Nov 30), $4/$20 (> Nov 30)

reply
Argon and Carbon are the same class model. Carbon is just a newer rev of it.

There is a Helix model too (in the pipeline) which is the actual small size.

reply
They use the very precise "it sounds cool". Neon is 75% the price of Carbon but has 4 extra protons in the nucleus and is also a noble gas. Argon is a heavier noble gas at 16 protons.

element/model - atomic number - cost H - 1 - $1.50 & 7.50 per mtok C - 6 - $4 & 20 per mtok Ne - 10 - $3 & 15 per mtok Ar - 16 - $2 & 10 per mtok

Claude - length of story but fable messes it up Haiku - 3 lines Sonnet - 14 lines Opus - a novel? Fable - 30 lines?? Mythos 15700 lines?

Luna - 28 days Sol - 365 days Astra - 5-6000 stars

reply
Everyone seems quite upset/perplexed by the Gemini naming scheme but I quite like it. And hey, if you find yourself lost, the periodic table is probably the most ubiquitous ordered list in the world and serves to clear things up pretty fast. This will likely not be strictly true as models release over time, but is a good rough indication of what the team thinks we should expect of the models, in the same way the other labs run their naming.

I also like the personalities implied by these, with Anthropic saying “human literary achievement is neat”, OpenAI saying “space is neat” and Google being like “science is neat”.

Edit: I was coming back to say “I wish we could talk about stuff more substantive than the naming scheme” but (1) my comment may be objectively incorrect, and (2) I have to apologize that I haven’t helped the situation by… commenting on the naming scheme.

reply
They are not following the periodic table in any discernible way though.
reply
They're in alphabetical order, almost like Ubuntu release names. There was a leak about a Gemini Oxygen model, which would further support alphabetical order -- skipping names they don't want to use.

So, names don't align with capability but instead "release freshness". This is unlike every other provider but it is what Google does (did?) with Android releases I believe (dessert names).

reply
They went form A to N in 4 releases. Initially maybe they planned to follow the alphabet, but I think that went out the window
reply
Lmao no. The most ubiquitous ordered list is... numbers. Or the alphabet.
reply
> And hey, if you find yourself lost, the periodic table is probably the most ubiquitous ordered list in the world and serves to clear things up pretty fast.

But the way google ranks the models by capability doesn't follow periodic table order.

Hydrogen - 1

Carbon - 6

Neon - 10

Argon - 18

It could very well be based on their density (g/cm^3 in standard conditions):

Hydrogen - 0.0000899

Neon - 0.000900

Argon - 0.001784

Carbon - 2.267

This would make more sense than assuming it is based on their periodic table order as it more accurately maps to how Google markets their capabilities, but is too esoteric to really be useful for clearing up confusion for normal users, IMO.

reply
The periodic table isn't really helping. Hydrogen is the lightest, that much makes sense. Beyond that it doesn't seem to work. The elemental ordering is H C Ne Ar. The cost ordering is H Ne Ar C (with Ar and C being the same per token but I gather that C thinks more and thus costs more). The capability ordering seems to be H Ar C Ne. Argon is the highest on the table but is neither the most expensive nor the smartest.
reply
deleted
reply
I think you mean say nobel size, I'd wait for radon.
reply
now we have to know our atomic weights to be able to choose which gemini model for the task, i suppose.
reply
Problem with Radon is that they will swap it out for Polonium without telling you, and then they will obsolete that in favor of Lead.
reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
[dead]
reply