upvote
I dont agree that Anthropics names are easy for an outsider, i'd have no clue what a Fable is compared to Haiku, to me both are just "story" names. OpenAI's new naming scheme is celestial bodies and i'd assume it's just size, bigger celestial body bigger performance, except i dont know where "Astra" fits since Sol > Terra > Luna at least make sense. Now gemini... I was just thinking it today that "Carbon" and "Hydrogen" with hydrogen being the lightest element? Is that what they are going for? I wouldn't know off the top of my head where Neon and Argon are placed though.

Edit: Just as I post this someone else comments google's doesnt follow elemental sizes at all so my theory is wrong too!

reply
I'm obviously thick, but this is the first time it's dawned on me that the Claude names were types of written work. Now I'm wondering why Opus isn't the top model; isn't an opus a more impressive (or at least larger) piece of work than a fable?
reply
I don't have a cohesive explanation for each one, but in my mind a fable is basically a legend (or in other words, a myth/mythos) and a legend is the final form of a story. Even though it has been half forgotten and changed, it still lives on, affecting people across times greater than a human's short life.
reply
A fable is just a story with antropomorphized animals and a moral. They can get very short.

Here's a translation of the entire Fox and Grapes fable:

> Driven by hunger, a fox tried to reach some grapes hanging high on the vine but was unable to, although he leaped with all his strength. As he went away, the fox remarked "Oh, you aren't even ripe yet! I don't need any sour grapes." People who speak disparagingly of things that they cannot attain would do well to apply this story to themselves.

reply
An opus is just a musical composition, sometimes also used about written work, but it doesn't really imply a great work. Maybe you're thinking of "magnum opus"?
reply
The point is that Haiku was Haiku a year ago, and the number keeps increasing, while googles gemnini started with sane names and numbers as 1,2,3.x pro/flash/lite, and is now suddenly continuing with 4 hydrogen/argon/neon/carbon something.
reply
For me, it is familiarity that does the work. I'm familiar with Sonnet, Opus and Fable and what they mean to me. The same is true for Sol and Astra bu I'm not sure about Terra or Luna.

So I'm just hoping for consistency over some period of time to allow me to get familiar.

reply
No way Claude is obvious without prior knowledge
reply
Prior knowledge of common poetic forms taught in middle school?

The point is that there is prior knowledge that completely explains the entire system. A 3 line poem < a 14 line poem < a book-sized work < a multi-book epic, boom done, easy. Consistent and friendly using words that everyone should know.

With google we have element 1 < element 18 < element 10 < element 6. There is no consistent schema where their namesakes map to their relative sizes, price, and capability.

reply
While I agree that Anthropics naming makes more sense, I also doubt most people know the periodic table that well
reply
> A 3 line poem < a 14 line poem < a book-sized work < a multi-book epic

So wait, which is smarter - Fable or Opus? It's clearly not obvious to most people or this debate wouldn't be happening.

As the old saying goes - if you're explaining, you're losing.

reply
Valence electron counts don't even work either. The noble gases are in the middle! It's insane!
reply
You are now claiming a Fable is a poetic form?
reply
They still require prior knowledge of Latin words of celestial bodies or different words for literary works, same as Google's requires knowledge of the periodic table.
reply
> Google's requires knowledge of the periodic table

The problem with Google's is that knowledge of the periodic table doesn't seem to help.

reply
Damn, if only the people concerned with what the naming of AI models mean had access to some magical technology they could use to ask what the names of those models mean.
reply
What would knowing the periodic table tell you about google's models? They are not in order of atomic units! Hydrogen (1) < Neon (10) < Carbon (6)
reply
They could have used a generative “*gen” theme with some of the most fundamental elements: Hydrogen, Nitrogen, Oxygen.
reply
Don't forget last month's Argon (18) which is better than Hydrogen (1) but worse than Neon (10).
reply
ASCIIbetical order, obviously!
reply
The number of replies arguing that the OpenAI and Claude naming is confusing doesn’t bode well for human intelligence
reply
I mean, they're OK, still a bit cryptic. Astra in particular is a bit ambiguous - they're all named after celestial bodies then the largest is just named after space in general.

Would love "small", "medium", "large", "extra-large", etc...

reply
mistral does this
reply
Astra means "stars"
reply
The Sun is a star itself. More stars are better? What about white dwarfs?

Systema would have worked. And maybe galaxias after that.

reply
Astra is basically all of systema and galaxias
reply
Having named a range of sizes more than few times by now...S/M/L/XL always starts out great and then turns into a MESS of XS, XXXL, Medium-Large, forever and ever.
reply
Yeah, or you get an escalatory scale. Similar to how LF/MF/HF (low/medium/high frequency) got "very HF", "ultra HF", "super HF", "extremely HF", "tremendously HF".
reply
Google used to do that with a version number and descriptor. 2.5 Pro, 3.1 Flash-Lite, etc. Gave you both model generation + idea of relative size/quantization within generation. I guess they decided that scheme wasn't flashy enough?
reply