upvote
> Apart from one friend having issues receiving notifications, overall, we are having a positive experiene on ElementX/Matrix.

My experience started like this: Good at first, but there was a slow burn of people encountering random issues with no clear solution. Fixing the first few was a team effort. Then everyone starts to get tired of debugging the latest issue someone has. Then that person needs to talk to someone so they talk on another platform, with others following over time.

Group chat is a product where it has to work for everyone in the group. Unless you have a dedicated IT person for the group who will tirelessly solve everyone’s problems for them when they don’t have time or energy to do it, the slow attrition from random problems either splits the group or nudges everyone to an easier platform.

I hope they’ve made progress on fixing some of the random issues and user unfriendly sharp edges over time because it could be a great platform.

reply
TBH I have to routinely open Teams on my iPhone to get any semblance of reliable notifications.

It's been this way across two different orgs.

reply
> Apart from one friend having issues receiving notifications

That is exactly the issue that keeps this project from being successful. We tried it multiple times with non tech people who often had budget android phones.

Not using GCM / FCM resulted in battery drain (like 70% compared to other apps) and not receiving notifications for weeks, because these people did not open the app on a regular basis. It really sucked.

reply
On ElementX it's the opposite problem for me: I get constant notifications for EVERY message on Android, even when I'm using desktop. There is a decade-old issue for it on GitHub: https://github.com/element-hq/element-meta/issues/360

I genuinely don't understand how anybody can use this in a commercial setting. Imagine if Slack was pinging your phone for every message you received while using the desktop app. No serious company would adopt it.

reply
The very issue that made me finally abandon the whole thing for good in 2023 after trying a multi-device setup the first time, with Element X on the mobile. This was after trying it on and off throughout the years, and generally being pretty excited about it. Pure madness when you consider #360 was opened in 2015 and modern IM is something that Matrix was supposed to be a good fit for.
reply
It's what made me stop using the app to follow certain open source projects. I understand it's a hard problem, especially while maintaining privacy, but it was too much distraction.
reply
I had issues with the old Element app on mobile (not on my computer). ElementX seems to have sorted the notification issues though.
reply
deleted
reply
This is why I decided to use mattermost
reply
The #tacticool chat.
reply
I don't think a for-pay-only, ultra-corpo "Sovereign Operations & AI for Critical Infrastructure and National Security" solution, headquartered in Palo Alto is going to count as equivalent (or even alternative) to an open source technology primarily used by a company with an equally open source product located in the UK.

You might as well go "that's why I decided to use the paid tier of whatsapp": the whole point of matrix is that you control who sees your data.

reply
Mattermost is open source and can be self hosted for free.
reply
So we are back to square one regarding notifications on mobile devices, right?
reply
I disagree here. In my opinion, not receiving notifications is probably a bug somewhere that can be fixed, its just a technical limitation.

If instead you use Whatsapp, the lack of privacy, and you being the product, is not a bug that can be fixed, its the whole business model, and it will never change.

reply
> not receiving notifications is probably a bug somewhere that can be fixed, its just a technical limitation

Users don't care whether it is a bug or a "technical limitation" or whatever else, and rightfully so.

The expectation of a messaging app user is that message notifications arrive in a timely manner. This is straight up one of the primary features of any messaging app. If a messaging app cannot even do that, it is a no-go, full stop.

The whole "privacy issues" and "business model" talk is not something an average user cares about. They want their messaging experience to work smoothly and all primary features of messaging (such as notification delivery) to work in a way where they don't have to think about them at all.

reply
RCS was their best attempt at a cross platform service, and it has silent failure rates of over 50%, forcing me to stop using it entirely.
reply
I've been on Android since Gingerbread but RCS makes me want to get an iPhone. No idea how Google thought shipping it with worse reliability than SMS/MMS was acceptable.
reply
Replied to a message: Yeah it's pretty bad.
reply
This is not my experience. I dont doubt it is your experience, but you surely must mean 50% of your messages not 50% of the cohort because RCS is now deployed worldwide at scale to BILLIONS of people and if 50% were failing, we'd know.

RCS is normalised, and works at the same reliability as SMS for the vast majority of the global messaging community.

reply
> RCS is normalised, and works at the same reliability as SMS for the vast majority of the global messaging community.

Not at all, no. Among my non-technical acquaintances they all (all, not just some subset) complain that RCS is unreliable seemingly at random some small fraction of the time. However it works most of the time and (unlike SMS) you can send high resolution pictures and (in particular) videos so they continue to complain about it rather than switching. (There are various downsides to any of the options they could switch to.)

reply
Not receiving notifications is very tangible and a complete no-go for a lot of people.

An unspecified lack of privacy on an E2E app feels less palpable and not a blocker for a lot of people.

reply
True. Bit it's also that if teams, discord, fb messages or whatsapp drops a notification - there's nothing you can do - it's just a fact of life.

If you're hosting your own foss stack you get to take ownership of every gremlin - for better or worse - each problem becomes something you should be able to fix.

reply
if the bug is in android itself the eu commission can just block sell of phones wherw the app does not work and I imagine it will be fixed in one week
reply
How did you convince them to switch?

In my experience, most people just don't care enough

reply
My online friend group made the switch earlier this year when Discord was really pushing on the ID verification thing.

We just made detailed instructions and stuck to locking the discord server by a certain date. Everyone who cared to interact moved over either then or shortly after when they noticed that the server was locked. I think this mainly worked out because we were willing to let go of anyone that would neither speak against switching nor make the switch.

reply
Is there a true discord alternative that can have multiple servers in one client, screenshare, voice chat, attachments and so on ?

Maybe also api-compatible with discord ? I have a discord bot that I would like to keep running

reply
Orwell is aiming at becoming something like that. (No idea about API-compatibility though.) https://github.com/magnuslab-sudo/orwell
reply
spacebar.chat but I haven't followed in a while so I'm not sure how good it is
reply
switch from discord is a very important tidbit you should not have left out.

it completely change your anecdote

reply
In the long ago times, when I and a few others were trying to get our friends to switch away from Facebook Messenger, nothing worked to convince them for years. Then someone read an NY times article, and soon everyone switched.
reply
What kind of NYT article? About some alternative? Or about some data scandal of FB?
reply
About Signal. The part of the group most attached to Messenger largely had a vague 'Zuck is evil' assumption already.
reply
If you stop logging in regularly to the other ones, people eventually move over when they don't want to wait a day or two for a response. Just make it clear you're only on matrix 24/7, anything else you're just not active on. (Which means uninstall the mobile apps, too.)

Also, Discord's id scan rollout was extremely effective in motivating my friend group. I don't think any of them even got directly hit by it (yet), but we've all had other issues with their faulty AI bans and account flags and losing accounts due to them that it wasn't a tough sell for us.

reply
I know people who switched to whatever app flavor of the day it was when they switched. I just never talked to them anymore. I'm not installing 5 other apps because some person decided to use while the rest of the world is still on the other app.
reply
Depends on what you value more I guess.
reply
The person leaving values the continued communication just as little, so these sorts of problems are usually non consequential.
reply
I have a dozen message apps on my phone, but I run graphene so I don't worry as much with them each being sandboxed. Oddly ElementX is the only one I have notification issues with.

I get a notification from somebody which opens the app and I can read it.

reply
It helped that we are all working in technical jobs and met while studying Computer Science...

The trigger for us was the proposed ChatControl law by the EU.

reply
How does it help with Chat Control? My understanding is it proposed to capture data on the client device, bypassing E2E regardless if it's WhatsApp, Signal, or other app.
reply
Even though it's indeed client side, I think the idea is to enforce implementation of this not as an OS component, but as an App component. Each app would have to inspect their data. In this context, the ability to roll one's custom clients puts you outside of ChatControl's reach

(don't take my word for it, I only skimmed the subject)

reply
Thankfully more and more institutions actually start to care about it!
reply
+1, I couldn't care less if Zuckerberg himself is tracking my live en route from my place to a friend's

I'm just a commoner with avg habits that have seen 0 consequences in 30 years of live from the Evil Corps using my (already easily available) data

reply
Yes and if someone is not a commoner but a journalist investigating corruption in your city he can be - as has happened to many journalist worldwide - targeted because you only focus on immediate first order effects to you.
reply
You’ll have to explain the connection between GP using WhatsApp and journalists being targeted, it’s not obvious.
reply
Journalist's investigating corruption are people (among others) who stand out - statistically and mathematically - compared to people "minding their own business". Therefore privacy violating "features" help a lot with messing with those people.

You may have heard spyware operators using mobile adds to target and infect journalists.

reply
Ok.

If you use a product or service you support what they are doing. You can see this has effect in anti-boycott retaliation.

There is a fast food joint here in town with an owner who beats up his wife every day. He also screams at her in front of customers. The food is great, a lot of choice, very affordable, service is fast. It might not change anything that I wont eat there. Lots of people don't eat there for the same reason.

I use whatsapp because to many people cant see the connection.

reply
I don’t understand why that caused the hypothetical journalist to take the risk of using platforms that would expose them though?
reply
They might take the risk, it also might not be obvious for what you are going to get persecuted in the future and to what extend.
reply
by declaring themselves as a commoner, they are not saying "journalists don't exist"
reply
Funny enough, the best way I heard this argument refuted was from Designing Data Intensive Applications:

  Perhaps you feel you have nothing to hide—in other
  words, you are totally in line with existing power
  structures, you are not a marginalized minority, and you
  needn’t fear persecution. Not everyone is so fortunate.
reply
Can you be sure about that? What if you purchased things and voted for politicians because of well placed targeted content?

We all feel like we're in control of our decisions, but if advertisers are paying for ads and seeing increased sales, some of us must be buying things.

reply
The best trick of the devil is making people think he doesn't exist.

If these companies are so obsessed with the avg person data and their revenue is in the tens of billions per quarter, it follows that there must be any consequence deriving from them having your data, even if you don't think you have seen it.

reply
There are three technologies I can name which are making me more concerned with privacy and data collection:

1. AI-powered "personalized pricing" for obvious reasons. 2. Advertising. Effective advertising captures my attention (a scarce resource) and "creates demand" in my brain for products I otherwise wouldn't need. No TV ad has ever led to me purchasing something, but Instagram ads and YouTube affiliate marketing fuel my B.A.S. (bike acquisition syndrome). 3. Predatory apps like sports gambling and MMORPGs. Like advertising, these are designed to create addiction and using personalized data makes it all the more effective.

While I am also a commoner with avg habits, I would like to protect myself against sophisticated attackers like Instagram Ads, RuneScape, DraftKings, and predatory pricing at the grocery store. Giving up my privacy and data gives the attacker an advantage (they know how to manipulate me).

None of this has anything to do with government surveillance. We all hope for philosopher kings who wield Palantier with grace and dignity, but history has more examples of despots using technology to oppress us commoners :(

reply
Would you care if your chat/location history allowed a court to link you to a crime by constructive presence or circumstantial evidence even if you were innocent of that crime? Would you care if you served years in prison due to that "evidence"? Of course, that would never happen, would it? (check https://exonerationregistry.org for examples)
reply
It’s a feature not a bug. If they won’t switch they aren’t serious people and they are better off staying elsewhere. My community lost more than half of its members and we have been using Matrix for over a year.
reply
Same but with XMPP! Much easier to host (there is an order of magnitude difference in resource consumption). Although my client can't do live location, only manually sending the current point.
reply
Why is the resource consumption of the Matrix server implementations so high? What are they doing that hits so heavy on performance? Encryption? But isn't it e2e? State resolution? Surely the resolution algorithms can't be that bad?

Even Dendrite, the eternally-WIP-rewrite in Go, used so much RAM I couldn't even start it on my Raspi.

reply
The reason Matrix typically consumes more resources than XMPP is because it's replicating a large DAG of state events (i.e. the key-value data associated with a room; not the room's actual messages) between all participating servers. So, in a room with 100K users, each server has to maintain at least 100K state events (every time someone joined a room, or changed their name, or left the room, or set permissions, or changed the room's name etc).

Then, whenever the state of the chatroom changes (e.g. you join it, or someone else joins it), each server has to resolve its view of the state of the room with the proposed change. We call this merge conflict resolution algorithm 'state resolution', and it's typically where the heaviness comes from, as a naive implementation loads up all the state events for the room in order to calculate and store the new state.

In exchange, you get fully decentralised access control, and an eventually consistent zero-trust distributed key-value store, with resilience to network partitions (including in P2P environments) - unlike (say) vanilla XMPP which applies access control and KV on a single given server per-conversation.

Now, the key thing is that *there is nothing in the protocol which makes this intrinsically heavy to implement*. The only reason that servers can be heavyweight today is simply because more time has been invested in chasing down more pressing issues like encryption issues, investing in client SDKs, speeding up sync responses, switching to OIDC for auth, etc.

The problem is made worse by the fact that Synapse (the original Python server) has historically been particularly clunky, skewing perception. Over the last few years this has improved significantly, although it could still be way better - at the Matrix Conference last month (https://youtu.be/kdEDxI2MCjA?list=PLFDUAtPqCX98&t=329) we showed off a fork which had improved CPU 10x by shifting the hot path entirely to Rust from Python. (It turns out that over 2026, we wrote as much Rust for Synapse as we did Python, ignoring tests). Further improvements would be to memoize the state res and calculate it incrementally rather than starting from scratch every time. Similarly, there are 100x improvements to be had on storage usage - e.g. by storing state temporally (c.f. my https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1pKtLl4vCV3-8xz8crvxW... spike from last year).

So, why haven't these improvements landed yet? In practice, the team at Element who builds Synapse have had to focus on customer-driven work instead in order to keep the lights on, and frustratingly performance is lower down the todo list than other feature-work. On the plus side, over the last year or so Element has got into a much healthier state - hence us being able to show off the 10x improvements in Synapse last month (although they still need to land).

Meanwhile, elsewhere in Matrix there are other servers which are more actively focused on being lightweight right now (e.g. continuwuity), but don't have the maturity of Synapse (or the commercially supported distribution that Element provides). And even then, there's still a lot of headroom for speeding up and shrinking things - it should be very very doable to run Matrix on a tiny host like an RPi.

It's not a perfect analogy but I think of it as being similar to the evolution of DVCS systems. There's nothing intrinsically heavy or hard about replicating DAGs of source code between hosts, but Monotone was pretty slow and clunky while Git showed that a smarter implementation could be more than performant enough. The race is on to build the equivalent for Matrix.

reply
Unless things have changed a lot in the last few years, it’s state resolution.

And yes the algorithms are tough - especially if you’re in the bigger rooms with lots of servers that don’t always work right.

reply
You should try alternative homeserver implementations of Matrix! From private benchmarks, https://continuwuity.org/ can serve over 1,000 simultaneous clients on 1gb of RAM.
reply
Any specific reason why you didn't go with Signal to replace Whatsapp or did you just not consider it at all?
reply
In addition to what others have said, Signal does not allow forks to use their servers, see [0][1]

With that and no federation, the freedom to modify is hampered. Sure, you can do whatever you want with the software, but you can't reach out to people on the platform if you do it (the whole point of a chat app).

Edit: added source [1]

[0] https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issueco...

[1] https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/9966#issu...

reply
> Signal does not allow forks to use their servers,

They make noise and other devs have so far respected their wishes (a fact which I find frustrating) but they have no ability to enforce such demands. It's also beyond me why anyone views the signal project in a positive light at this point. They want to ride on the coattails of the FOSS ethos while attempting to curtail the spirit of being completely free to tinker, fork, and interoperate to your heart's content. People should use projects with more ethical maintainers.

reply
Signal requires disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization and agreeing to their terms.
reply
Signal is a non profit with robust terms that forbid monetisation of data.

The data you share is minimal anyway, and can’t be used to decrypt any messages.

It’s not suitable for any industries that require any form of record keeping or auditing, the minimal tradeoffs are well worth it, given that you don’t have to stand up your own solution.

reply
Promises don't matter if you don't have a technological guarantee. Promises can be broken and governments can make companies break promises.
reply
There is a technical guarantee with Signal, and their ability to cooperate with governments has already been tested, when the FBI came to Signal with a court order for all information they had on a given user, and Signal turned over everything they had: the user's sign up date.
reply
For years now, Signal has uploaded people's entire contact lists to their server, protected only by Intel SGX that is infamously vulnerable. I use Signal myself, and suppose that its chats themselves may be reliably E2EE. But it's a reasonable assumption that a nation-level actor has access to contact metadata, not just the bare facts Signal says it discloses when authorities come calling.
reply
I don’t think that’s a reasonable assumption at all; have you seen what it takes for those SGX exploits to work? There is no way Signal would continue to operate if someone required them to do that.

theoretically possible and practically implementable are two entirely different things.

reply
> have you seen what it takes for those SGX exploits to work?

It is absolutely trivial for an operator to intentionally compromise the latest generation of trusted computing from both intel and amd. See https://tee.fail/ for a nice writeup.

tl;dr Currently CPUs reuse nonces meaning the solution is unfit to defend against an operator with physical access. It can only defend against rogue neighbors (ie other guests).

reply
Signal uses rented cloud infrastructure. No one needs to require them to do anything.
reply
The alternative is running your own hardware, which won’t protect you from the “nation-level actor” you mentioned. They’ll just come in with a warrant and take it.
reply
Where did I suggest one can protect themselves? Personally, I don't believe that a strong state like the US would permit in 2026 a general-public service to exist that it does not have access to for the metadata.
reply
There is a technical guarantee that anything that is encrypted now might be decrypted in the future thanks to advancememts in technology.

While hosting your own servers do not prevent any gov from recording all your net traffic, it might just not even be aware of it while signal is an obvious target as it is known to being used by the press, gov officials and other criminal groups.

reply
The government could force Signal to begin storing more data without disclosing it to the users.
reply
Some people (like me) simply don't like the idea of being at the mercy of any single particular entity. No amount of convenience or practicality is going to convince those people that Signal is worth adopting. If I am going to go through the hassle of getting my friends and contacts out of WhatsApp, then I'd rather just skip Signal and go straight to a protocol that supports multiple clients and does not have its preconceived notion about how people should communicate.
reply
> Some people (like me) simply don't like the idea of being at the mercy of any single particular entity.

Is the person hosting the Matrix instance not the single particular entity you are now at the mercy of?

I'm not trying to be glib, it's a genuine thought. I also love the idea of using self-hosted solutions for everything but more often than not it just means putting all the trust/responsibility on the one person willing to maintain the whole thing.

reply
Valid point, and there are p2p/decentralized approaches such as White Noise that builds on Nostr and MLS (RFC 9420) [0]

[0]: https://www.whitenoise.chat/

reply
No. Hosting a matrix service is a commodity. Search for "matrix hosting" and you will find plenty of providers. As long as you have your domain and a data backup you can change seamlessly. What can you do if Signal stops being a good alternative?
reply
> Is the person hosting the Matrix instance not the single particular entity you are now at the mercy of?

to some degree, but you could migrate to a different or your own instance without needing to convince your contacts to do the same.

reply
We're also in the process of (slowly) adding account portability to Matrix - I demo'd the first ever (rather anticlimactic) migration at the matrix conf last month: https://youtu.be/U5LRRNgvTZE?list=PLFDUAtPqCX98&t=1082
reply
You’re at the mercy of whoever is hosting your Matrix instance.

Also, every matrix instance in the world has to forward their notification pushes for every iOS user in the world to vector.im, the matrix vendor, to be relayed to Apple.

So, if you use iOS, you are at the mercy of at least 3 entities.

There are also lots of Signal clients, and they’re all free software.

reply
That's an incorrect evaluation of push notifications.

Because of the way push notifications work on iOS, they are end-to-end encrypted and relayed via a push gateway operated by the person that deployed that client to the app store. For Element clients, this is Element Creations. For other clients, there are other operators with no relation at all. If you build your client from source, it's you.

As far as the server and protocol is concerned, it just sends notifications where the client tells it to.

reply
Yes, vector.im (new vector ltd) changed their name to Element Creations because they still haven’t learned the lesson that having a company name different than your product name is dumb. Countless startups have re-learned this lesson.

Regardless, that’s why I said pushes and not push notifications, but they are all indeed relayed through one entity, formerly named New Vector and now named Element (and if they are successful then eventually named Matrix). They’re the publisher of the iOS app and iOS apps can only receive pushes from their publisher.

All of this handwaving about distributed this and selfhosted that and it all relies on some small VC-backed startup’s instances in realtime. If those go down the app effectively goes down because nobody on iOS gets notifications. Same goes for when some hobby sysadmin’s non-HA deployment goes offline for a day or two.

reply
There is no "the app". For my personal usage I don't use any apps published by Element, and as such do not rely on any of their infrastructure. I develop my own server [0], my friends develop their own clients[1][2][3]. When my server went down I switched to one hosted by someone I know, and then switched back when it was up. Decentralisation and interoperability are not theoretical.

[0]: https://forgejo.ellis.link/continuwuation/continuwuity [1]: https://github.com/gomuks/gomuks [2]: https://git.sable.moe/sableclient/sable-next [3]: https://git.federated.nexus/Nexus/nexus

reply
> So, if you use iOS, you are at the mercy of at least 3 entities.

To be pedantic here, you can communicate without notifications.

reply
No, you can spin up a new container at another hoster with your backup.
reply
The phone thing is no go for communication system used mainly on PCs, it's a chore and annoyance.

Plus lack of any org level management

reply
Messages and calls to phone numbers are also interceptable, so it's a security nightmare in general.
reply
Signal does not use the phone number for anything except account registration
reply
Then why even have it?
reply
To prevent bots from easily creating accounts. Cost-wise it is very effective and non-profits have to make costs manageable.
reply
So is proton and they look to be taking a turn for the worse
reply
The 501c3 corporation named Signal can see all metadata and can see what users messaged what other users at what time. This 501c3's centralized namespace is hosted on Amazon Web Services, which can and will also see all that metadata.

Among people competent with computers, vendor lock-in is something to avoid, not embrace ; they don't perceive someone else hosting their server instances as "convenient" but as something else.

Use Signal Desktop long enough after leaving whatever "phone" in a drawer long enough and you'll see

  Open Signal on your phone to keep your account active
The 501c3 corporation named Signal is a vendor who abuses those foolish enough to use its service.
reply
deleted
reply
no it doesn't require disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization
reply
How do you register without a phone number or a mobile phone or a bank card with your name on it?
reply
You cannot. I have tried but there is always a signal to a real person.

This is trivial but because none of these services offer a true end to end encryption without cell phone number or credit card the ability it leads me to believe there can be no long lasting, widely adopted secure service that is not potentially compromised by a State government.

Even if you procured a burner card or cell you are operating in a window of possibly illegally or spam adjacent which would result in the closing of the account or criminal suspicion.

reply
[flagged]
reply
> to a commercial organization

You mean the Signal Technology Foundation, the non profit is a comercial organization?

reply
We wanted to self host in case of the EU Chat Control law taking effect. But we are also a small group of young people so we can just easily move on to another service, hence we didnt overthink on whether to use Matrix or Signal. And in the end, Matrix/ElementX works quite well for us
reply
It's really great that you are using Matrix, I've never managed to convince even one person to use it (so I'm alone, messaging myself). In my opinion Signal will get you a similar result, but with less issues. It's much easier to convince people to use it, it feels more familiar to what people already know.

Sure, Signal is dependent on the Signal Foundation and their servers. They could also somehow abuse that position. But it also has some benefits. Sending messages through the Signal network makes users rather anonymous. When your devices connect to a Matrix server, even the encrypted communication tells something (exchanging messages with users on this particular matrix server). Captured Signal traffic just says there were some messages exchanged with one or more of the 100 million Signal users.

reply
> Sure, Signal is dependent on the Signal Foundation and their servers

You can host it yourself if you want to; the code quality isn't amazing, and the public code lagged behind the clients for quite some time last I looked, and it makes a load of assumptions about specific cloud services you'll use, and error checking is non-existent, so you have to work around some bootstrapping issues because it falls over if you have no users or data on first start, but if you sort all of those things out, it works nicely. source: I worked on a private fork of it for a few years for work. I always wanted to release a proper cleaned up, self-hostable version of it but wasn't able/allowed contractually.

> Sending messages through the Signal network makes users rather anonymous

Not only that, but it uses something called "sealed sender", so other than a record of an IP coming in, there's nothing that can tie the sender of a message to the message unless you can decrypt it; the sender is inside the encrypted part, like a sealed envelope.

reply
Then why are they so all-fired determined to tie you to a phone number? Even the "username" method ultimately ties you to an identity because you have to pay the nominal fee via trackable method.
reply
Spam. Otherwise there wouldn't be any limit to create bot accounts.
reply
Other services have a model where effectively anonymous users can message users who sent an invite token out of band.

The whole "we need a phone number or bank card to combat spam" narrative is crap.

reply
Signal is mostly used by people who want to message their phone contacts. That's what it's for. If you don't like that, just use something different.
reply
Signal is for messaging other people.

This thing you are calling a "phone", it's a computer that runs Linux or Darwin.

Signal is not for messaging people using a "phone" that is not a "smart phone".

Signal is not for messaging other people specifically because they have a non-neutral identifier on a closed network (the PSTN). This is not what Signal is for. Any notion that this is what Signal is for, is horse shit, prima facie.

Some users of the permissioned centralized namespace hosted by the 501c3 corporation named Signal have asked me to "get on Signal". A token embedded in an invite URL generated by that user should be sufficient for another to message that user.

The PSTN numbers in the early days were vestigial, and now they are an unnecessary burden.

There is no excuse for demanding a PSTN number, or a Google account and a bank card.

_

> just use something different.

Yep that's what ends up happening.

reply
you must be fun at parties
reply
This is a text forum dubbed "Hacker News", not some in-person social gathering you made up in your head.

I appreciate your affirmative admission you lost the argument.

reply
Honestly I don't know; some of the decisions I've seen them make over the years have been eyebrow raising; many of them I didn't agree with, but it's their system, they can do what they want.

We ripped out all of the phone number and SMS code stuff and used an arbitrary identifier.

reply
> because you have to pay the nominal fee via trackable method.

They use a zkp to delink the payment from the account, so while you do need to identify yourself for the payment, that's where it ends.

reply
My whole family switched to Signal basically on a whim from whatsapp and as far as I can tell don’t really miss whatsapp at all. I will say though a lot of countries have whatsapp fairly deeply entrenched so hard to get away from the network effects.
reply
> Sending messages through the Signal network makes users rather anonymous

I'm sure you know the caveats that apply but I'll state this for others who'd read this and truly think Signal is 100% anonymous

Anonymity is a spectrum, and Signal only gets one so far. I'd subjectively rate it a 7/10 on the anonymity spectrum

reply
I did this with chatmail.at and delta.chat it’s SOOO much simpler to host than matrix and federation is also transparent.

Not to mention that you can host chatmail on a potato

reply
Yes. And it is cool to have an address that is tarpit.fun. :)
reply
I'm not alone! I have found it rare to find fellow chatmail fans :)

Mine is at danneskjold.de

reply
Do you also federate?

Connect with other matrix servers? As far as I understand, this is the hard part and makes scaling difficult. (One of a servers user joining a group on a different server will make its original server load all that group data as well and that sums up)

For your use case I also considered setting up a instance. Connecting a cluster of friends. But it would be nice if it could grow a little bit, without problems and the server choking.

reply
> live location with this friendgroup and be very confident that noone is harvesting this data.

Cell tower based location data is widely available for a small fee for anyone if you have their phone number.

reply
What other platforms/protocols did you consider?
reply