upvote
This was my question after reading the article, it calls it “proprietary” which I found puzzling for a public library
reply
Dewey Decimal system is proprietary too.
reply
Oh, wait, is this how Project 2025 gets to privatize and enshittify libraries or something?
reply
Yeah:

https://www.deschuteslibrary.org/about/news/news?NewsID=3136...

Where they say they still use the Dewey decimal system, just under a new 2-layer of categorization... As usual, FastCompany is all fluff and overselling. It should really be throttled down on HN as a low-quality source.

Back to the Wayfinder system, it is described as "proprietary". I hope it is a broadly inaccurate adjective, one of the good things with the Dewey system is its universality.

reply
> I hope it is a broadly inaccurate adjective, one of the good things with the Dewey system is its universality.

To be specific, "universal" here means "there was a guy named Dewey who created a taxonomy" and not "there is one true universal taxonomy" (which we all know is false.) Dewey is imperfect, in particular for areas of knowledge that didn't really exist when Dewey created it, e.g. "Artificial Intelligence" today, but even "Radio" or "Motion Pictures", etc. librarians basically have to create whole new categories. Special collections are particularly challenging.

Without the need to be universal, Wayfinder is free to focus on whatever goals the Bend libraries have for it, unencumbered by the endless toil of trying to build a perfect index.

reply
The other place that Dewey was deficient in was Fiction. Dewey assigned no numbers to the entirety of Fiction. Fiction is a huge part of the world of books. Libraries generally have to have large fiction catalogs. Most libraries have always used something like Book Store Categories then alphabetical to organize Fiction. Wayfinder sounds like it is sort of better systematizing that classic 2-system approach to me, based on the broad descriptions I've read so far.
reply
Fortunately there's no shortage of numbers, so a Dewey-like system should be infinitely able to accomodate new subjects.
reply
deleted
reply