upvote
Pre-internet it worked well enough. The chess books were in one section, the programming books in another.

I'm not sure I understand how that's different than Bookstore layouts.

My library did have display tables for the new books or award winning books e.g. Hugo award winners/ NY times bestsellers

Learning how to use microfiche was a game changer.

reply
Bookstores are organized somewhat more broadly by category. Publishers assign BISAC codes to books to tell the bookstore where to shelve a book. A title can have more than one BISAC code, and the code can encompass subcategories.
reply
Any attempt to categorize "all books" into some system that by physical necessity will yield exactly one answer for where some book in some specific library will go will be poor. (That is, even if the DDS or some other system yields multiple valid categorizations for some particular book, in some specific library the book has to live in one specific place.) Some may be somewhat better than others, but "poor" is the best you can hope for. Even ontologies far more lively, rich, and constantly being kept up-to-date, like the systems for classifying scientific papers, fail to really correctly capture the full complexity of the real world.

In the 21st century we can use computers to sort on any number of dimensions and by any criteria we want and tell the user where the book is directly. Once we've embraced that, it frees the physical organization of the books being optimized for sheer findability by anyone, ever, into whatever other system we like. "Hey, bookstores seem to have evolved this layout as the best way to introduce books to people over the decades" is at least a decent start. I would expect the library would want to evolve some nuances on that based on the fact they're not looking to maximize profits, but it's probably a good start.

reply
> The internet always seemed completely enthralled by the by the Dewey Decimal System, but it always seemed like a pretty poor way of locating books at the library.

Huh? It isn't a way of locating books at the library, poor or otherwise. The point of the Dewey Decimal System is to have a deterministic way to put the books on the shelves.

reply
It work very well when the card catalogue was still a card catalogue.

And when libraries were maintained by librarians.

reply
The card catalogue was susceptible to misplaced cards, and wasn't great for more generic searches (ex finding the gardening book that is categorized as history), something a modern computer based card catalog should be much better at along with indicating checked out status/etc.

But this goes back to the basic idea that you shouldn't need to browse the library if you have a specific goal, you look up the topic and pick out the book from the stacks after looking at the book summary in the catalog. OTOH, if your just there for some fiction, then sure go directly to that section and browse.

reply
> The card catalogue was susceptible to misplaced cards, and wasn't great for more generic searches (ex finding the gardening book that is categorized as history)

Misplaced cards, yes, but the point of the card catalogue is that a history of gardening book is listed under gardening and history.

reply